An open-access law journal applying a double-blind peer-review system, published by PT Meja Ilmiah Publikasi, and committed to credible, relevant, and high-integrity scholarly publication.
SINTA Rank 3 Decree of the Director General of Science and Technology No. 355/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026 View accreditation document About the Journal
Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum is an open-access journal that applies a double-blind peer-review system. Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum has been accredited SINTA Rank 3 based on the Decree of the Director General of Science and Technology Number 355/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026 , dated July 24, 2026, concerning the New Accreditation Rankings for Scientific Journals for Period 3 of 2025.
The journal focuses on the development and dissemination of original legal research. It provides an academic platform for researchers to publish empirical and normative legal studies that offer solutions to various contemporary legal issues. Its scope covers Environmental Law, Civil Law, Criminal Law, Constitutional Law, Administrative Law, Customary Law, and Islamic Law.
We invite researchers to submit manuscripts that comply with the scope and quality standards of Adagium. Every manuscript will undergo a rigorous evaluation process through a double-blind peer-review system. The final decision regarding manuscript acceptance is entirely at the discretion of the Editorial Board, based on recommendations from peer reviewers.
Journal Information
| Journal Title | Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum |
|---|---|
| Subject | Law |
| Languages | English and Indonesian |
| E-ISSN | 2985-5128 |
| Publication Frequency | Twice a year, in January and July |
| DOI | DOI Prefix 10.70308 — Crossref |
| OAI-PMH | Access OAI-PMH Records |
| Editor-in-Chief | Dr. Febrian Chandra, S.H., M.H. |
| Publisher | PT Meja Ilmiah Publikasi |
| Citation Analysis | Google Scholar |
| Accreditation | SINTA Rank 3 |
Current Issue
Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum
Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum is a periodical academic journal published by PT Meja Ilmiah Publikasi. This journal specifically studies law and is able to present various results of current and prominent scientific research. The journal's administrator accepts articles that contribute to the development of law and the environment from scientists, academics, professional writers, and researchers. This journal contains research findings, summaries of famous figures, or reviews that are innovative and solution-oriented in the field of law. Articles in this journal are published twice a year, in January and July.
On Process
Published: 2026-07-27
Articles
Legal Certainty in Qualifying a Mortgage Right Creditor as a Bona Fide Third Party in the Confiscation of Assets Derived from Corruption
788-802
This study examines the legal qualification of mortgage creditors as bona fide third parties in the confiscation of assets related to corruption and evaluates the legal certainty of their protection. It employs normative legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches. The analysis focuses on the Mortgage Law, the Anti-Corruption Law, Supreme Court Regulation Number 2 of 2022, the United Nations Convention against Corruption, and the principles of legal certainty, justice, and utility. The study finds that a mortgage creditor may qualify as a third party because the creditor holds an independent registered security right and stands outside the offender's criminal liability. Good faith requires more than a valid Mortgage Certificate; it also depends on a genuine credit transaction, lawful registration, prudent examination of the collateral, reasonable timing and value, and the absence of knowledge or involvement in the offence. Existing law provides a substantive basis for protection but remains procedurally uncertain because Supreme Court Regulation Number 2 of 2022 does not expressly include mortgage creditors among eligible applicants. Legal certainty therefore requires explicit procedural standing, adequate notice, balanced evidentiary burdens, and a clear remedy, such as preserving the mortgage, separating the secured amount from sale proceeds, or paying the verified outstanding debt before the remainder is recovered by the state.
Analysis of the Proof of the Element of "Premeditation" in Judgment Number 551/Pid.B/2025/PN RAP: A Review of the Judge's Considerations Regarding Evidence
967-977
This study analyzes proof of the element of premeditation (voorbedachte raad) in Judgment No. 551/Pid.B/2025/PN Rap. Because the offense and judgment occurred in 2025, the temporally applicable offense provision is Article 340 of the former Indonesian Criminal Code, while Article 459 of Law No. 1 of 2023, effective from 2 January 2026, is used only as a prospective comparison. Using normative legal research with statutory and case approaches, the article evaluates whether the facts described in the judgment demonstrate a calmly formed intent, a sufficient opportunity for reconsideration, and execution that was not merely an immediate emotional outburst. No fixed time interval is treated as determinative; premeditation must be inferred from the complete factual sequence and the court’s legal reasoning.
Transformation of Marriage-Guardian Authority in Contemporary Muslim Society: The Limits of Family Intervention in Spouse Selection
1283-1296
This study analyzes the transformation of marriage-guardian (wali) authority in contemporary Muslim society and formulates the appropriate limits of family intervention in spouse selection from the perspective of Islamic law. It asks how guardian authority has shifted from coercive power toward consent and accompaniment, and how the boundary between protective and restrictive intervention can be formulated operationally. The study employs qualitative library research using normative-juridical and socio-historical approaches. Primary materials include the Compilation of Islamic Law and marriage legislation, while secondary materials consist of journal articles and previous studies, all examined descriptively, analytically, and interpretively. The findings show that the transformation of guardian authority proceeds asynchronously because Islamic thought, positive law, and social reality change at different speeds. Legitimate intervention should be determined by the existence of dharar (harm) affecting the substance of marriage under the framework of maqasid al-shari'ah, rather than by family social status or subjective preference. The guardian's role can therefore be reconstructed as that of a protective partner through the principle of mubadalah (reciprocity). This framework offers practical guidance for religious courts and Offices of Religious Affairs in balancing the protective function of guardianship with respect for women's autonomy.
The Status of Evidence in Tender Conspiracy from the Perspective of Ibn Qayyim Al-Jauziyah (A Study of KPPU Decision Number 17/KPPU-L/2022 and Supreme Court Decision Number 523 K/Pdt.Sus-KPPU/2024)
1563-1584
Indirect evidence in bid-rigging cases raises the question of when circumstantial indications become legally sufficient proof. This article examines KPPU Decision No. 17/KPPU-L/2022, Supreme Court Decision No. 523 K/Pdt.Sus-KPPU/2024, and Ibn Qayyim Al-Jauziyah's concepts of al-bayyinah and qarinah. The study employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches and qualitative doctrinal analysis. It finds that indirect evidence is not a separate evidentiary category beyond Article 42 of Law No. 5 of 1999, but an inferential method based on recognized sources. KPPU regarded the initial tender cancellation, changes in the procurement team and documents, and the outcome of the repeated tender as evidence of coordination. The Supreme Court found the evidentiary connection between these events and prohibited cooperation insufficient. Within a comparative qarinah framework, these indications are more appropriately characterized as qarinah zanniyyah than qarinah qatiʿah. The article proposes a reasoned standard requiring established facts, clear inferential links, examination of lawful alternative explanations, and transparent judicial justification.
Fulfillment of Restitution Rights for Victims of Trafficking in Persons: A Study of Atambua District Court Decision Number 102/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Atb
1859-1866
A trafficking conviction does not automatically deliver the victim’s right to restitution. This normative legal study examines Atambua District Court Decision Number 102/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Atb, focusing on the relationship between the elements of trafficking, the rights of victims or heirs under Article 48 of Law Number 21 of 2007, and the procedural steps necessary for losses to be assessed and ordered. The supplied manuscript describes a conviction arising from recruitment and transportation to Malaysia and reports that the operative judgment did not include a restitution award. However, the documents supplied do not establish whether a restitution request, itemized loss calculation, prosecutor assessment, or witness-and-victim protection agency evaluation was submitted. The study therefore does not infer the judge’s motive or a judicial legal error without the authenticated complete judgment and relevant filings. It recommends a traceable procedure from identification of the claimant and quantification of losses through judicial reasoning, operative relief, and enforcement.
Judicial Reasoning on Imprisonment and Rehabilitation for Personal Narcotics Use in Limboto District Court Decisions
2138-2151
This doctrinal study examines judicial reasoning in three Limboto District Court decisions reported to combine imprisonment with medical and social rehabilitation. Statutory, conceptual, and case analysis addresses Decisions Nos. 54/Pid.Sus/2024/PN Lbo, 90/Pid.Sus/2024/PN Lbo, and 94/Pid.Sus/2025/PN Lbo. The case summaries report prison terms of eighteen to twenty-two months and six months of rehabilitation within a correctional institution. The analysis distinguishes personal use, addiction, and victim status, and evaluates the reasons for the sanction, treatment duration, and placement. A conviction under Article 127 does not itself establish clinical dependence or satisfaction of every rehabilitation criterion. Nor does the absence of an assessment report from the research materials prove that no assessment occurred. The article proposes a prospective model centered on individual assessment, structured judicial reasons, and authorized treatment suited to the defendant’s needs. The National Criminal Code, effective in 2026, informs reform proposals rather than automatically governing the evaluation of the 2024–2025 decisions.
Legal Certainty on the Transparency of Paid Product Rankings on Marketplace Platforms from the Perspective of Consumer Protection in Indonesia
712-730
This article examines transparency of paid product rankings on marketplace platforms through legal certainty, consumer decision-making, ranking transparency, and the boundary between commercial disclosure and protection of platform trade secrets. It uses normative legal research and a structured analysis of applicable legal materials, supported by comparative and interdisciplinary scholarship where relevant. The revised analysis distinguishes legal design from empirical claims and identifies the principal regulatory or institutional gap. The study finds that existing law provides important but fragmented safeguards and that legal certainty depends on clearer decision criteria, procedural accountability, and proportionate remedies. It proposes an operational framework that specifies legal thresholds, institutional responsibilities, safeguards, and review mechanisms. The article contributes a more explicit research gap, a reproducible doctrinal method, and a policy model calibrated to legality, proportionality, accountability, and rights protection.
A Legal Analysis of the Supreme Court's Legal Reasoning in Annulling the KPPU Decision in a Tender-Collusion Case (Decision No. 523 K/Pdt.Sus-KPPU/2024)
927-938
This study examines the differing interpretations between the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) and the Supreme Court regarding the evidentiary standard for tender collusion in Supreme Court Decision Number 523K/Pdt.Sus-KPPU/2024, as well as the legal grounds relied upon by the panel of judges of the Supreme Court in annulling KPPU Decision Number 17/KPPU-L/2022. KPPU had previously ruled that tender collusion occurred and imposed a monetary fine, a decision subsequently upheld by the Central Jakarta District Court. At the cassation level, however, the Supreme Court overturned the ruling on the grounds that no direct or indirect evidence was found indicating cooperation or a request from the tender participants to the project owner. This research employs a normative legal method with a qualitative approach, relying on secondary data consisting of primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials gathered through library research and analyzed descriptively. The findings show that the divergence between the two institutions lies in the standard of proof applied: KPPU considered it sufficient that one tender participant obtained a benefit, whereas the Supreme Court required two cumulative elements, namely a benefit to the tender participant and an agreement or request originating from that participant. This divergence indicates that the stricter evidentiary standard adopted by the Supreme Court provides greater legal certainty, but risks narrowing KPPU's authority to act against covert forms of tender collusion.
The Prudential Principle under Indonesian Banking Law: Its Implementation and Credit Compliance at BPR Barelang Mandiri in Batam City
1196-1218
The prudential principle is a central legal foundation of bank lending because it protects asset quality, depositors' funds, and financial-system stability. This study examines the legal framework governing prudential lending by rural banks (Bank Perekonomian Rakyat, BPR) and evaluates its implementation in credit compliance at BPR Barelang Mandiri in Batam City. It employs empirical legal research using statutory and case approaches. Primary data were obtained through interviews with personnel in marketing, risk management, collateral appraisal, and collections; secondary data were drawn from legislation, scholarship, and the bank's public financial report. The data were analyzed descriptively and qualitatively through Lawrence M. Friedman's legal system theory. The findings show that the bank translates prudential duties into 5C analysis, document and credit-history verification, functionally separate collateral appraisal, tiered approval, exposure limits, and post-disbursement monitoring. Yet a gross non-performing-loan ratio of 12.85 percent in March 2026 demonstrates a material gap between procedural compliance and the substantive effectiveness of credit-risk control. Stronger assessment of borrower character and capacity, closer monitoring of productive loans, continued inter-unit independence, and more systematic documentation of remedial action are therefore required.
Limited Material Truth in Civil Procedure: Objective Triggers and Safeguards for Judicial Intervention
1510-1523
Civil procedural law in Indonesia generally adopts the concept of formal truth, which is based on the facts and evidence presented by the parties in court. The application of this concept is related to the passive judge principle, which limits the judge's role in assessing the parties' arguments and evidence in order to maintain judicial neutrality and procedural certainty. However, the dominance of formal truth may create a gap between procedural and substantive justice due to economic disparities, unequal access to legal assistance, differences in access to information, and disparities in the parties' ability to present evidence. This study aims to analyze the weaknesses of the dominance of formal truth and formulate a limited material truth model in civil procedural law. This normative legal research employs statutory, conceptual, case, and philosophical approaches. The results show that formal truth has limitations in revealing the actual truth because it depends on the parties' ability to prove their claims. The full application of material truth may also potentially undermine judicial impartiality. Therefore, a limited material truth model is needed through objective parameters, including inequality between the parties, indications of evidence manipulation or abuse of legal process, and the need to realize substantive justice. This model is expected to balance legal certainty, procedural justice, and substantive justice.
Legal Certainty of Wage Determination as the Basis for Calculating BPJS Employment Contributions and Its Implications for Employer Accountability in North Sumatra
1744-1760
Workers’ social security protection depends on employers’ compliance with wage reporting and contribution payment obligations. This study examines legal certainty in determining wages as the basis for calculating BPJS Ketenagakerjaan contributions and analyzes its implications for employer liability in North Sumatra. It employs a normative-empirical legal research method with a descriptive-analytical approach, combining statutory analysis with empirical information obtained from interviews. The analysis focuses on Law No. 24 of 2011 concerning Social Security Administering Bodies, Government Regulation No. 44 of 2015, and Government Regulation No. 86 of 2013. The findings indicate differences in employers’ understanding of wage components, particularly the classification and reporting of allowances, as well as variations in payroll administration and workers’ access to contribution information. These conditions highlight the importance of clear regulatory guidance, accurate wage records, and effective verification procedures. The study also establishes that discrepancies between actual and reported wages do not automatically constitute criminal offenses. Criminal liability must be assessed based on the applicable statutory provisions, the elements of the alleged offense, and sufficient supporting evidence. Administrative noncompliance must therefore be distinguished from conduct that fulfills the requirements for criminal liability. The study recommends strengthening employer guidance, interagency coordination, wage-reporting verification, and workers’ access to complaint mechanisms. These measures can improve regulatory compliance, support the protection of workers’ social security rights, and promote consistent legal enforcement.
Protecting Children’s Economic Interests in the Post-Divorce Division of Marital Property: A Best-Interests Framework
2080-2088
This doctrinal article examines children’s economic protection when joint marital assets are divided following divorce. It distinguishes the former spouses’ ownership interests from child-maintenance duties and the child’s need for stable accommodation. Through statutory and conceptual analysis and qualified discussion of judicial materials, the article identifies a specific protective avenue in Supreme Court Circular No. 1 of 2022: a marital-property claim may be granted while implementation of division is deferred where the sole family home occupied by the child is proven, until the child turns twenty-one or marries. It proposes a proportionate, evidence-based assessment while rejecting the unsupported premise that children automatically receive an ownership share in the parents’ joint property.
Criminalizing Non-Consensual Sexual Deepfakes in Indonesia: Reconstructing Consent, Harm, and Digital Sexual Violence
1081-1101
Generative artificial intelligence enables the creation of synthetic sexual representations depicting an identifiable person even though no real sexual event occurred. This article evaluates the adequacy of Indonesian criminal law after the national Criminal Code entered into force on 2 January 2026 through normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and limited comparative approaches. Each regime is tested against the protected legal interest, conduct verbs, mens rea, victim and consent elements, stage of conduct, and available remedies. The study finds a partial normative gap: the Sexual Violence Crimes Law, Electronic Information and Transactions Law, Pornography Law, and Personal Data Protection Law can reach distribution, unlawful data processing, or particular forms of conduct, but Article 14 of the Sexual Violence Crimes Law does not, consistently with lex certa, clearly cover the creation of a new synthetic sexual file. As a de lege ferenda proposal, the article formulates a sexual-autonomy-based offence requiring identifiability, sexual character, intent, and specific absence of consent. The model distinguishes creation/manipulation, threats or coercive use, distribution, monetization, and repeated dissemination; treats actual harm as an aggravating factor; and separates criminal liability from regulatory duties concerning removal, preservation, and anti-reupload measures. Exceptions are assessed through necessity and proportionality to avoid overcriminalization.
Corporate Criminal Liability for Environmental Harm after the New Indonesian Criminal Code: Harmonizing Attribution, Organizational Fault, and Sanctions
547-566
The entry into force of Law Number 1 of 2023 on the Indonesian Criminal Code on 2 January 2026 places corporate criminal liability within the general architecture of national criminal law alongside pre-existing sectoral provisions. This article examines the relationship among the Criminal Code, the Criminal Adjustment Law, Articles 116-119 of the Environmental Law, and Supreme Court Regulation No. 13 of 2016. The juridical analysis separates attribution of conduct, organizational fault, individual responsibility, the relevance of administrative permits, and sanction calibration. The study argues that the Environmental Law remains a sectoral basis that must be read together with the Criminal Code's general corporate rules without converting every employee violation into corporate fault. A three-stage model conduct attribution, organizational fault, and sanction calibration is proposed as a reasoning framework that still requires proof of the underlying offence. Fines, disgorgement, restoration, compliance reform, and activity restrictions must be tied to their respective legal bases, institutional competences, and proportionality safeguards.
The Legal Status of Severance Pay as Statutory Compensation for Termination of Employment and Its Relationship with Civil Damages
745-764
This study aims to clarify the legal position of severance pay following the post-Job-Creation-Law reforms in Indonesia, specifically examining its relationship with civil damages. The central proposition is that severance pay constitutes statutory compensation arising ex lege under employment legislation, and is not, by itself, a form of damages for breach of contract. A lawful termination of employment may still trigger an obligation for statutory severance or other compensation depending on the legally specified grounds. Conversely, an unlawful or contractually wrongful termination may raise separate legal questions concerning the restoration of workers' rights or civil damages, provided that their specific legal elements are proven. This study employs a normative legal research methodology, utilizing statutory, conceptual, and case approaches to analyze the Indonesian Civil Code, employment legislation read alongside Law Number 6 of 2023, Government Regulation Number 35 of 2021, and selected industrial relations decisions. The analysis concludes that employment law fundamentally serves as the lex specialis starting point. Civil Code Articles 1243 and 1365 may operate only subsidiarily where a genuine normative gap or a separate civil wrong exists, and where loss, causation, legal basis, and jurisdiction are firmly established; they do not automatically enlarge the statutory severance formula.
Legal Protection of Anesthesia Practitioners in the Digitalization of SIPPA through SATUSEHAT
1143-1160
The digitalization of health workforce licensing is part of a broader transformation of health governance that places information systems at the centre of professional administrative processes. One of its implementations is the issuance of the Anesthesia Practitioner Practice License (Surat Izin Praktik Penata Anestesi/SIPPA) through a digital system integrated with the SATUSEHAT platform. Reliance on digital systems, however, also raises legal concerns, particularly concerning legal certainty and the protection of anesthesia practitioners’ personal data. This study examines the legal framework governing the digitalization of SIPPA following the enactment of Law Number 17 of 2023 on Health and analyses the legal protection of personal data during the digital licensing process. The study employs normative juridical research using statutory and conceptual approaches. Legal materials are analysed qualitatively by examining the relationship among the Health Law, the Personal Data Protection Law, Government Regulation Number 28 of 2024, and Minister of Health Regulation Number 13 of 2025. The findings indicate that digital SIP licensing has a sufficient legal basis, but its implementation must address licensing authority, data security and accuracy, and remedies for system failures. Legal protection for anesthesia practitioners therefore concerns not only the legality of professional practice, but also personal data rights and clear procedures when errors or disruptions occur in the digital licensing system.
Reconstructing a Progressive-Law-Based Model for Land-Dispute Resolution in Indonesia
1459-1468
This article reconstructs a progressive-law-based model for land-dispute resolution in Indonesia without displacing statutory authority, evidentiary rules, or judicial review. It uses normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches and codes recurring dispute patterns from selected legal scholarship and official land-dispute regulations. The study clarifies Indonesia’s negative land-registration publication system with positive elements: certificates constitute strong evidence but are not absolutely conclusive, while Article 32 of Government Regulation Number 24 of 1997 creates a five-year protection mechanism under specified conditions. The article identifies normative gaps in social-history verification, overlapping claims, power asymmetry, inter-agency data integration, and remedy coordination. Progressive law is operationalized through seven stages: intake and authority screening, integrated document and spatial verification, social-history verification, dispute typology, facilitated settlement, reasoned determination or referral, and post-resolution monitoring. Each stage is bounded by legality, evidence, proportionality, reasoned decision-making, and reviewability. The model distinguishes remedies within BPN authority, party agreement, and judicial jurisdiction, and proposes output, outcome, and safeguard indicators for future pilot testing.
Reconstructing Digital-Forensic Authentication of Electronic Evidence in AI-Era Criminal Proceedings
1681-1709
The development of artificial intelligence (AI) increases the risk of manipulating electronic evidence, while Article 235 of Law Number 20 of 2025 concerning the Criminal Procedure Code has not regulated in detail the technical mechanism for authentication. This research aims to analyze the adequacy of the authentication arrangement of electronic evidence and reconstruct the mechanism that ensures the reliability of criminal evidence in the AI era. The research uses normative legal methods with legislative, conceptual, and comparative approaches. Legal materials are collected through literature studies and analyzed qualitatively-prescriptively. Authentication arrangements are inadequate because the judge's authority is not balanced by technical examination standards, the support of digital forensic experts, and an integrated verification infrastructure. The research offers a forensically supported judicial authentication model through the Supreme Court Regulation (PERMA) and the Electronic Evidence Authentication System (EEAS). This model integrates evidence preservation, hash verification, metadata and provenance checks, AI manipulation detection, expert verification, and judicial assessment. The reliability of proof requires the integration of legal norms, technical competence, and institutional support. The novelty of the research lies in the reconstruction of layered authentication that connects the authority of judges with standardized forensic digital verification without shifting decision-making authority from judges.
Wives' Career Rights in Islamic Jurisprudence and Indonesian Family Law: A Doctrinal Reappraisal of Marital Partnership
2046-2055
This doctrinal study reassesses wives’ career rights by distinguishing divine revelation, juristic interpretation, and Indonesian positive family law. It analyzes scriptural recognition of women’s earnings, the classical concepts of maintenance and marital availability, and the relationship between the Marriage Law and the Compilation of Islamic Law. The study finds that employment by a wife does not, without additional findings, establish marital disobedience (nusyuz). It proposes a proportionate, evidence-based approach that protects lawful employment while examining actual effects on care, mutual obligations, and children’s interests. Suggested interpretive and statutory reforms are expressly distinguished from existing binding rules.
Reconstructing the Legal Responsibility of E-Commerce Platforms for Jahalah in Unlabelled Food Products: A Review of Consumer Protection Law and Islamic Economic Law
1183-1195
This article examines the legal responsibility of e-commerce platforms for transactions involving processed food products that lack legally required label information. Shopee is used as an object of contractual analysis, not as empirical evidence of the prevalence of unlabelled listings. The study is normative legal research employing statutory and conceptual approaches. It maps the Consumer Protection Law, the Food Law, Government Regulation Number 80 of 2019 on Trading Through Electronic Systems, BPOM rules on processed-food labelling as amended, the Halal Product Assurance regime, DSN-MUI Fatwa Number 110/DSN-MUI/IX/2017, and Shopee’s Terms of Service accessed on 19 September 2026. The study finds that primary labelling and information duties attach to businesses that produce or trade food, while platform responsibility must be assessed proportionately according to intermediary functions, system governance, notice-and-action mechanisms, and the limits of contractual disclaimers that cannot displace mandatory statutory duties. From the perspective of Islamic economic law, uncertainty concerning material product characteristics may amount to significant jahalah where it affects safety, halal status, product identity, or other elements material to informed consent in the contract. The article distinguishes obligations already supportable under positive law—such as information transparency, complaint handling, and action against unlawful content—from de lege ferenda reforms, including risk-based verification for selected food categories and a more structured notice-and-action mechanism. The study does not empirically measure seller compliance, consumer behaviour, listing prevalence, or platform response effectiveness.
Interfaith Marriage in Indonesia: Juridical Dilemmas and a Maqāṣid al-Sharia Reconstruction for the Legal Status of Children
978-993
Interfaith marriage in Indonesia presents a complex juridical dilemma arising from the interaction between religious family-law restrictions, constitutional rights, and population-administration rules. This study analyzes the normative relationship between the Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI) and the 1945 Constitution, examines legal uncertainty in marriage registration and its consequences for children, and formulates a maqāṣid al-sharia-based reconstruction aimed at protecting children’s civil rights. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, case-based, and limited comparative approaches, the study distinguishes the hierarchy and function of the relevant norms and separates current positive law from proposals for reform. The analysis finds no automatic or absolute contradiction between the KHI and the Constitution; restrictions must instead be assessed within the constitutional framework of lawful and proportionate limitations. The principal concern lies in administrative and normative uncertainty that may burden children’s identity, parentage, and other civil rights. A reconstruction grounded in ḥifẓ al-nasl and maṣlaḥah al-ṭifl supports regulatory harmonization, clearer civil-status procedures, institutional reform, and convergence with the best-interests-of-the-child principle. These reforms should protect children without treating administrative registration as an automatic validation of an otherwise invalid marriage.
The Urgency of Isbat Nikah in the Dynamics of Living Law: A Sociology of Law Analysis of Unregistered Marriage in Indonesia
1297-1314
This study analyses the gap between the statutory duty to register marriages and the practice of unregistered (siri) marriage that persists as living law in Indonesian society, the social and legal consequences of unregistered marriages, and the urgency and limits of marriage validation (isbat nikah) as a bridge between the two. It employs juridical normative research combining statutory and conceptual approaches. Data were drawn from primary legal materials, official figures released by the Ministry of Religious Affairs and the civil registry, and findings of prior studies, and were analysed qualitatively through Eugen Ehrlich's theory of living law and Lawrence M. Friedman's legal system theory. The findings show that siri marriage persists because religious validity has become the dominant social norm while registration is perceived as a mere administrative formality, a perception reinforced by economic and geographical barriers and low legal literacy. Women and children bear the greatest vulnerability concerning maintenance, marital property, inheritance, and legal identity. Isbat nikah functions as a recognition mechanism that transforms a marriage valid under living law into one acknowledged by the state; however, it is used largely reactively and may be misused to legitimise unauthorised polygamy or child marriage. Isbat nikah should therefore be situated within a policy framework that balances curative and preventive functions through strengthened legal awareness, integrated services, and judicial prudence.
Implementation of Electronic Signatures in Official Document Management: An Analysis of Legal Certainty and Legal Effectiveness at UIN K.H. Abdurrahman Wahid Pekalongan
1585-1600
This study aims to analyze the legal certainty and implementation effectiveness of electronic signatures (TTE) within the electronic official document management system at UIN K.H. Abdurrahman Wahid Pekalongan, as well as to identify the factors influencing their application. This study employs a legal research method using an empirical juridical approach. Data were collected through literature review, interviews, and observations, and subsequently analyzed qualitatively using legal effectiveness theory and policy implementation theory. The findings indicate that the implementation of electronic signatures is currently underway, supported by consistent leadership and adequate electronic signature applications. However, its effectiveness remains sub-optimal due to the lack of comprehensive internal regulations governing usage procedures, validity assurance, and troubleshooting mechanisms for electronic signatures. Furthermore, staff understanding and dissemination still need improvement, the electronic certificate renewal process requires multi-tiered coordination with the Ministry of Religious Affairs and the Electronic Certification Center (BSrE), and incoming mail disposition is still carried out manually. Based on these findings, it is necessary to strengthen internal regulations, enhance human resource competencies, plan electronic certificate renewals, and establish standardized mechanisms for handling technical issues. Consequently, the effectiveness of electronic signature implementation relies not only on technological availability, but also on regulatory certainty, human resource readiness, and integrated institutional governance support.
Criminalization of AI-Based Sexual Deepfakes in Indonesian Criminal Law: The Urgency of Victim Protection in the Generative AI Era
2018-2045
Sexual deepfakes generated by artificial intelligence (AI) have transformed image-based sexual abuse by enabling realistic intimate depictions of identifiable persons who never participated in the depicted acts. This study examined whether Indonesian criminal law, as applicable after the national Criminal Code took effect on 2 January 2026, adequately criminalized the non-consensual creation and circulation of AI-generated sexual representations and protected victims. The study addressed a gap in Indonesian scholarship by evaluating the post-2026 interaction among the Criminal Code, the Sexual Violence Crime Law, the Personal Data Protection Law, and the amended Electronic Information and Transactions Law, while comparing recent European Union and United Kingdom approaches. A normative legal method was used with statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches, supported by thirty recent Scopus-indexed journal articles published in 2022-2026. The analysis found fragmented protection: pornography provisions can reach circulation but do not clearly capture private creation; electronic sexual violence provisions presuppose recording, transmission to a recipient, or electronic stalking; and personal-data offences protect data processing rather than sexual autonomy as such. The study proposes a technology-neutral offence covering intentional creation and solicitation of synthetic intimate depictions without consent, with separate and aggravated liability for distribution, threats, monetization, repeated conduct, and child victims. It contributes a victim-centered model that treats the primary protected interests as sexual autonomy, dignity, and digital identity, rather than deception alone.
Construction of Proof in Divorce Cases Involving Adultery Allegations: An Analysis of Two Religious Court Decisions from the Perspective of Maqāṣid al-Syarī‘ah
2152-2169
This study examines the evidentiary construction of relationships with third parties in divorce proceedings and their relevance to establishing continuous disputes and quarrels as grounds for divorce. It also analyzes the judges’ considerations in granting divorce from the perspective of maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah. This research employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. The data were collected through library research by examining relevant legislation, Islamic jurisprudence literature, and two court decisions: Decision No. 3997/Pdt.G/2019/PA.Kab.Mlg of the Malang Regency Religious Court and Decision No. 1072/Pdt.G/2024/PA.Mlg of the Malang Religious Court. The findings indicate that neither court established adultery as a legally proven fact. Instead, relationships with third parties were treated as factors contributing to marital disputes. The evidentiary process focused on demonstrating the breakdown of the marriage, as reflected in prolonged conflicts, separation, and unsuccessful reconciliation efforts. From the perspective of maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah, granting divorce may be understood as an effort to prevent continuing harm through the protection of life, the balancing of competing interests, and consideration of the consequences of legal decisions. This study clarifies the distinction between proving adultery and establishing marital breakdown in divorce proceedings.
Prohibiting Political Deepfakes in Election Campaigns Based on the Principles of Honest and Fair Elections
731-744
This article examines the need to prohibit manipulative political deepfakes in Indonesian election campaigns and formulates a regulatory model aligned with the principles of honest and fair elections. This normative legal research uses statutory, conceptual, and case approaches to analyze existing regulatory gaps. The results indicate that current legal instruments, such as the Election Law, the Electronic Information and Transactions (ITE) Law, and electoral management body regulations, remain partial. These regulations lack specific operational mechanisms to address artificial intelligence (AI)-based identity manipulation that significantly threatens electoral integrity and voter autonomy. As an implication and answer to these issues, this study proposes a more proportionate legal framework. The proposed model includes a specific prohibition on political identity falsification, mandatory AI content labeling, rapid clarification and content removal mechanisms, and institutional coordination guidelines among the KPU, Bawaslu, Kominfo, and digital platforms. The implementation of this model strengthens legal certainty in responding to digital disinformation in a measured manner, ensuring that the purity of voter intent remains protected without suppressing freedom of expression, such as legitimate satire.
Judicial Validation of a Private Land Sale and Purchase Agreement as a Basis for Registration of Transfer of Title: A Study of Medan District Court Decision No. 995/Pdt.G/2024/PN Mdn
939-953
Land is a crucial natural resource for human life from economic, social, and legal perspectives. Legal certainty in the transfer of land ownership rights requires an understanding of the distinction between the validity of sale and purchase agreements under civil law and the administrative requirements for land registration. In practice, many land transactions are conducted informally without involving a Land Deed Official (PPAT), thereby raising questions about their legal force. This research examines the validity of informal land sale and purchase agreements based on the Decision of the Medan District Court Number 995/Pdt.G/2024/PN.Mdn using normative juridical methods and a statutory approach. The analysis demonstrates that a sale and purchase transaction, according to Articles 1457-1458 of the Indonesian Civil Code, arises from the agreement of the parties, while the validity of the agreement must satisfy Article 1320 of the Civil Code- namely, agreement, capacity, definite object, and lawful cause. However, civil validity does not automatically result in the transfer and registration of ownership rights, as a PPAT deed is required in accordance with Government Regulation Number 24 of 1997. In the aforementioned decision, the judge considered the settlement of Rp95,000,000, delivery of the original certificate, physical possession for 11 years, and the consistency of witness testimony before ordering the registration of the right transfer. In conclusion, informal agreements can be legally binding under civil law, whereas PPAT deeds retain their preventive and administrative functions. The decision reflects justice, legal certainty, and administrative order, while providing judicial remedy for good-faith buyers.
Juridical Analysis of Civil Liability of Livestock Business Actors for Environmental Pollution
1270-1282
This study examines the construction of civil liability for livestock business actors causing environmental pollution through the relationship between Article 1365 of the Indonesian Civil Code and the special regime under Law Number 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management, as subsequently amended under the Job Creation framework. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and limited case approaches. The study finds that liability cannot be determined merely from the sectoral label of a livestock enterprise. Article 1365 remains relevant where a claimant must establish an unlawful act, fault, loss, and causation, while Article 87 of the Environmental Law strengthens compensation and environmental-restoration obligations. Article 88 continues to use the concept of absolute liability, although the post-Job Creation wording has generated debate about the applicable evidentiary standard. Ordinary organic livestock waste is not automatically classified as hazardous and toxic waste; consequently, Article 88 should not be applied solely because pollution originates from a farm. Its use requires a functional assessment of the activity, including the use or management of hazardous substances or waste and whether the activity creates a serious environmental threat. The article proposes a risk-based and evidence-based liability framework, supported by scientific evidence and the polluter pays principle, to reconcile legal certainty for business actors with effective protection of affected communities and environmental restoration.
Individualized Sentencing in Severed Group-Assault Cases: A Comparison of Kolaka District Court Decisions Nos. 44 and 61 of 2023
1524-1536
This article examines the relationship between the separation of criminal case files (splitsing), proof of joint violence, and individualized sentencing in two Kolaka District Court decisions arising from a single group-assault incident: No. 44/Pid.B/2023/PN Kka and No. 61/Pid.B/2023/PN Kka. It applies normative legal research using statutory, case and conceptual approaches, with a structured comparison of charged conduct, evidentiary basis, individual participation, prosecutorial demands, mitigating circumstances and final sentences. Three defendants in Decision No. 44 received ten-month custodial terms, while four defendants in Decision No. 61 received six-month terms. Those outcomes differed alongside prosecutorial demands of fifteen and ten months respectively. The existence of disparity does not establish injustice because the defendants’ roles and procedural circumstances also differed. However, the decisions as described in the available case summaries would benefit from more explicit reasoning connecting each defendant’s acts and personal circumstances to the sentence imposed. Splitsing is a procedural device, not an autonomous ground of unequal punishment. The article proposes a nonbinding, reviewable comparison matrix that safeguards evidentiary independence while encouraging transparent proportionality analysis. Law Number 1 of 2023 is discussed only as a prospective normative benchmark and is not applied retroactively to the 2023 judgments.
Music Royalty Payment Policies in Restaurants from the Perspective of Maslahah Mursalah
1780-1799
The commercial use of music in restaurants creates economic value for operators while raising questions about the remuneration owed to composers and related-rights holders. This article examines the royalty regime under Indonesia’s Copyright Law No. 28 of 2014, Government Regulation No. 56 of 2021, Minister of Law Regulation No. 27 of 2025, and Constitutional Court Decision No. 28/PUU-XXIII/2025, and evaluates its consequences for restaurant operators, particularly micro and small enterprises, through the lens of maslahah mursalah. The study employs normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches and qualitative analysis of primary legal materials and scholarly literature. It finds that restaurant music royalties have a sound statutory basis, but their substantive legitimacy depends on transparent calculation, traceable distribution, proportionate tariffs, and accessible relief for smaller businesses. Maslahah mursalah supports the protection of creators’ economic rights as an aspect of hifz al-mal while requiring safeguards against disproportionate burdens on users. The article proposes an accountability-oriented framework combining legal certainty, transparent licensing, proportionate business classification, verifiable distribution, and effective review procedures.
Recontruction Article 244(5) of Indonesia’s Criminal Procedure Code to Protect Defendants’ Personal Liberty
2089-2098
This article examines Article 244(5) of Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code and its implications for a defendant’s personal liberty after a judgment releasing the defendant from all legal charges (ontslag van alle rechtsvervolging). The normative analysis distinguishes such a judgment from an acquittal, prosecutorial appeal from an independent detention decision, and lawful justification from excuse. A limited questionnaire of twenty-six participants provides only descriptive perceptions: a reported 76.9 percent opposing the rule is neither representative of national practice nor evidence of unconstitutional application. The study argues for individualized judicial assessment of the legality, necessity, and proportionality of any continued detention. It proposes a statutory amendment under which an appeal would not automatically extend detention, while preserving judicial authority to issue a new, reasoned and reviewable order where lawful conditions are met.
The Gap Between Das Sollen and Das Sein in The Implementation of Rehabilitation for Perpetrators of Sexual Violence
618-644
This article asks whether the discretionary rehabilitation measure for perpetrators of sexual violence under Article 17 of Indonesia’s Law Number 12 of 2022 on Sexual Violence Crimes (the TPKS Law) satisfies the doctrinal elements of an enforceable double-track sanction; if not, whether the resulting gap stems from the norm’s design or institutional capacity. Using a normative juridical method (statutory, case, and conceptual approaches on primary, secondary, and tertiary materials, without field data), the article develops a four-element doctrinal test, measure type, triggering criteria, implementing authority, and enforcement consequence, and then applies Soerjono Soekanto’s five-factor test of legal effectiveness to explain the gap. Article 17 satisfies only one element in full; the other three are absent or partial, a design defect compounded by delayed implementing regulations, national prison overcrowding of 86 to 89 percent, and the absence of a ready executor under an adjacent regime. Unlike prior studies, which describe the gap only in general terms, this article isolates Article 17 from the adjacent chemical castration regime under Government Regulation 70/2020 and supplies a testable doctrinal standard and explanatory framework, informed by a comparable implementation case from Uruguay. The resulting reform proposal, a rebuttable presumption bounded by proportionality safeguards, follows directly from the doctrinal finding and is conditioned on preserving judicial discretion and the victim-centered protections the TPKS Law already secures.
Implementation Of Asset Confiscation Mechanism For State Finance Recovery In Corruption Criminal Acts At The North Sumatra High Prosecutor's Office.
840-853
Corruption entails not only criminal liability but also the recovery of state financial losses through asset tracing, freezing, seizure, confiscation, substitute-money enforcement, execution, and asset return. This study examines how these mechanisms are implemented at the North Sumatra High Prosecutor's Office and identifies normative, evidentiary, institutional, asset-management, and cross-jurisdictional constraints. It combines normative and empirical legal approaches through legislation, scholarly literature, available institutional materials, and interviews conducted in August 2026 with an official responsible for the relevant asset-recovery function. The findings show that asset recovery must be differentiated according to its legal basis: confiscation of assets connected to the offence, seizure as a procedural measure, and execution against a convicted person's property to satisfy the additional penalty of substitute-money payment. Implementation is constrained by concealment and transfer through third parties, evidentiary difficulties in linking property to the offence, limited asset-tracing capacity, depreciation of seized property, and the need for domestic and cross-border coordination. The article's specific contribution is to demonstrate that institutional effectiveness cannot be inferred from case volume alone, but must be assessed through the institution's legally grounded capacity to identify, secure, prove, execute, and return asset value to the state.
Ruang Bersama Indonesia: A Gender-Responsive and Socially Inclusive Criminal Law Policy Model
1219-1236
This study analyzes the normative construction of criminal law policy in protecting women and vulnerable groups and formulates Ruang Bersama Indonesia as an integrative model of penal and non-penal policy, rather than as a new criminal law regime. This study employs a normative legal research method using statutory and conceptual approaches. The findings indicate that protection has developed through the principles of non-discrimination, victim protection, recognition of power relations, accessibility, reasonable accommodation for persons with disabilities, restitution, compensation, and recovery; however, these standards remain dispersed across various legal instruments and have not yet been fully connected operationally. The proposed Ruang Bersama Indonesia model places substantive justice as its objective, while legality, attribution of authority, human rights, and due process of law serve as boundaries, with gender perspectives and intersectionality as analytical foundations. Ruang Bersama Indonesia functions as a hub for prevention, information, initial assessment, assistance, and referral; meanwhile, investigative, prosecutorial, adjudicative, and professional service authorities remain with legally authorized institutions. This model requires vulnerability assessment standards, referral protocols, data protection mechanisms, institutional coordination, and measurable evaluation indicators.
Halal Certification as an Instrument of Consumer Protection and MSME Empowerment: An Islamic Economic Law Analysis of Contemporary Regulatory Challenges
1388-1401
This article examines halal certification as an instrument of consumer protection and micro- and small-enterprise empowerment from the perspective of Islamic economic law, focusing on the regulatory architecture that will govern the October 2026 mandatory-halal phase. It employs normative legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches. Primary legal materials include the Halal Product Assurance Law, the Consumer Protection Law, Government Regulation No. 42 of 2024, and BPJPH regulations verified through 4 October 2026; secondary materials are limited to directly relevant academic literature. The study finds that the certification obligation is phased and differentiated by product category and business scale, while the halal-declaration route provides a specific mechanism for qualifying micro and small enterprises. A halal certificate constitutes legally recognized administrative evidence of halal status, but consumer protection remains dependent on continuing halal-assurance duties, post-certification supervision, and accessible remedies. From a maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah perspective, protection of religion, life, and property must be balanced with maṣlaḥah, justice, and the removal of hardship. The article proposes risk-based supervision, integrated complaint and redress pathways, and legally tiered policy recommendations so that mandatory certification can protect consumers without imposing disproportionate burdens on micro and small enterprises.
Legal Protection of Banking Customers in the Resolution of Banking Investment Disputes between Indonesia and Malaysia
1710-1727
Legal protection for customers in banking investment disputes plays a crucial role because the relationship between customers and financial institutions is often unequal—in terms of information, bargaining power, and access to redress mechanisms. The differences in the legal structures of Indonesia and Malaysia are worth examining because both countries recognize customer protection but have distinct regulatory frameworks and dispute resolution mechanisms. This study employs a normative legal methodology using a legislative and comparative law approach. The legal materials used include Indonesian and Malaysian legislation, as well as legal literature related to customer protection, banking investments, and the resolution of financial services disputes. The results of the study indicate that Indonesia has a fairly broad legal framework for protection, but its regulations remain scattered across various legal instruments, making the avenues for protection and redress not yet fully understandable to customers. Malaysia demonstrates a more integrated approach through its financial services sector regulatory framework and an ombudsman mechanism that provides a more targeted dispute resolution pathway. The effectiveness of legal protection is determined not only by the existence of legal norms but also by the clarity of the structure, the accessibility of forums, and the integration of dispute resolution mechanisms.
Investor Protection in Sharia and Conventional Securities Crowdfunding: A Comparative Study of SHAFIQ and Santara
1937-1948
Securities crowdfunding (SCF) gives the public a new way to invest in small businesses. However, investors face the risk of loss, difficulty selling their shares, and uncertainty over who is responsible when problems arise. This study aims to explain the legal relationship among investors, issuers, and operators, and to compare investor protection on the SHAFIQ and Santara platforms. It employs normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The legal materials consist of regulations, official platform terms, share offering documents, and scholarly literature, which are analyzed qualitatively using Financial Services Authority (OJK) Regulation Number 17 of 2025 and Philipus M. Hadjon’s theory of legal protection. The results show that SHAFIQ emphasizes sharia principles and the operator’s working obligations, whereas Santara emphasizes the operator’s position as an intermediary and its responsibility for the accuracy of information. Both platforms contain investment risk warnings. Information disclosure and clarity of investor rights constitute preventive protection, while complaint handling and dispute resolution constitute repressive protection. Platforms and regulators need to ensure that platform terms comply with the regulations and that the responsibilities of each party are clear. This study is limited to the available documents; future research should therefore examine transaction agreements and complaint data.
Civil Liability for Artificial Intelligence-Induced Harm in Indonesia: Reconstructing Fault, Causation, and Evidentiary Responsibility through a Control-Risk-Evidence Model
1063-1080
The deployment of artificial intelligence in financial services, electronic commerce, health care, transportation, education, employment, and data-driven decision-making expands the possibility of harm that can no longer be explained solely through direct human conduct. This article examines the adequacy of Indonesia's civil-liability framework for losses caused or mediated by AI systems and develops a reconstruction model compatible with tort, breach of contract, consumer protection, electronic transactions, and personal-data protection. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and limited comparative approaches, the article finds that Articles 1365, 1366, and 1367 of the Indonesian Civil Code remain doctrinally relevant but encounter serious attribution and evidentiary gaps where AI systems are opaque, adaptive, distributed across multiple actors, and technically documented by defendants rather than victims. The article proposes a Control-Risk-Evidence Model that allocates responsibility according to practical control, economic benefit, capacity to prevent harm, and access to evidence. The model combines documentation duties, rebuttable presumptions of causation, stricter liability for high-risk deployment, and contribution-based recourse among responsible actors. It therefore preserves the corrective and preventive functions of civil liability without treating AI either as a new legal person or as a universal excuse for human and corporate actors.
The Ex Officio Authority of Judges in Determining Post-Divorce Maintenance: Integrating Sharia Norms and National Law in the Protection of Women and Children
854-873
Divorce frequently leaves women and children vulnerable when court decisions fail to specify the amount and the mechanism for fulfilling maintenance obligations. This study addresses three questions: how sharia norms and Indonesian national law regulate post-divorce maintenance owed to former wives and children; how the judge's ex officio authority to impose such obligations is construed juridically within the religious courts; and how the two normative systems are integrated so as to strengthen that authority. Employing normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches, it examines primary legal materials comprising the Qur'an, hadith, and national law, analysed descriptively and analytically. The findings indicate that sharia treats child maintenance as a paternal obligation that does not lapse with a change in marital status, and obliges the former husband to provide iddah, mut'ah, and madhiyah maintenance commensurate with his actual capacity. Positive law translates these norms through Article 41(c) of the Marriage Law, Article 24(2) of Government Regulation Number 9 of 1975, Supreme Court Regulation Number 3 of 2017, and a cumulative series of circular letters that have progressively widened the scope of ex officio authority. Integration operates at the level of legal reasoning and rests on maslahah and substantive justice, so that ex officio authority is not a deviation from the ultra petitum partium principle but a juridical instrument for closing the gap between normative guarantees and the actual fulfilment of rights.
A Juridical Analysis of Evidence for Trading Imported Processed Food without a BPOM Distribution Permit (Judgment No. 438/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Pbr)
954-966
This study aims to analyze the legal considerations of judges in proving the case of illegal imported food products without a distribution permit from the Food and Drug Supervisory Agency (BPOM) in Decision of the Pekanbaru District Court Number 438/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Pbr, as well as to analyze whether the evidence in the decision is in accordance with criminal law provisions and laws and regulations concerning food. This research employs a normative legal research method with a descriptive-analytical approach, using a statutory approach, a case approach, and a conceptual approach. The legal materials used consist of primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials, which were collected through library research and analyzed qualitatively. The results of the study indicate that the legal considerations of the panel of judges in the case were based on an assessment of the evidence and facts revealed during the trial in determining the fulfillment of the elements of the criminal offense as regulated under Article 142 in conjunction with Article 91 paragraph (1) of Law Number 18 of 2012 concerning Food. The proof in the case was conducted by relating the evidence presented at trial to the defendant's act of distributing food products that did not have a distribution permit. Based on the analysis, the evidence considered by the panel of judges was related to the provisions of criminal procedural law and the applicable laws and regulations concerning food, thereby providing a basis for the judges to find the defendant proven to have committed the criminal offense as charged. Therefore, the legal considerations of the judges in Decision Number 438/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Pbr demonstrate the application of criminal evidentiary provisions in determining the fulfillment of the elements of a food-related criminal offense involving food products without a distribution permit.
Applying the Unexplained Wealth Doctrine as a Basis for Confiscating Corruptors’ Assets: Formulating a Fair Reversed Burden of Proof and Strengthening Its Application to Law-Enforcement Officers
1315-1330
Asset recovery in Indonesian corruption cases remains constrained because confiscation generally depends on criminal proceedings and proof linking property to a predicate offence. This study examines the legal legitimacy of the unexplained wealth doctrine, formulates a proportionate reversed-burden model, and assesses the need for stronger scrutiny of assets held by law-enforcement officers. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, case, and comparative approaches. The study finds that shifting the evidentiary burden can be designed consistently with the presumption of innocence when it operates within an in rem mechanism and only after the State establishes objective grounds showing a material disparity between assets and lawful income. The article proposes a tiered balanced reversed-burden model consisting of an objective trigger, a prima facie burden on the State, an opportunity for the asset holder to establish lawful origin on the balance of probabilities, and a judicial determination accompanied by procedural safeguards. For law-enforcement officers, the mechanism should include independent examination to reduce structural conflicts of interest. This formulation may serve as a reference for future Indonesian asset-recovery reform.
Legal Protection in Fiduciary Security Disputes between Creditors and Debtors
1604-1616
Fiduciary security supports financing against movable assets by allowing debtors to retain possession while granting creditors priority in repayment. Disputes arise when default is contested, surrender is refused, or collection develops into unilateral repossession. This article examines proportionate protection for creditors and debtors across creation, registration, default, collection, enforcement, and dispute resolution. It uses normative legal research with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches, supplemented by limited functional comparison through the literature. The analysis draws on the Fiduciary Security Law, Constitutional Court decisions, financial services consumer protection rules, and scholarship. Protection beyond the certificate's enforcement authority requires valid registration, objective default clauses, documented collection, evidence of voluntary surrender, third-party oversight, and access to dispute resolution. The article proposes a three-stage model covering creation and registration, default and collection, and enforcement and its aftermath. The model integrates certainty of security rights, due process, and accountability for market conduct.
Reconstructing Muslim Family Maintenance Obligations amid Economic Uncertainty: Integrating the Fiqh of Mu‘sir, Maqāṣid al-Usrah, and Household Economics
1867-1892
Unemployment does not necessarily establish a husband's inability to provide maintenance, while employment does not guarantee sufficient provision. This doctrinal study examines capacity, fault, and legal consequences under economic uncertainty. It combines Indonesian marriage law and comparative fiqh with Ibn Ashur's family-oriented maqāṣid, Auda's systems approach, Becker's allocation of time, and Sen's account of cooperation and conflict. Capacity depends on accessible resources sufficient for basic needs; fault requires separate examination of conduct and constraints. Four quadrants distinguish employment status from capacity and culpability. Relief for hardship must preserve wives' and children's rights. Collaborative maintenance should specify expenditure and care responsibilities, property sources, reimbursement grounds, and review arrangements. A rebuttable presumption of reimbursement is proposed for proven expenditure of separate property replacing the husband's unfulfilled maintenance obligation. The reconstruction retains maintenance duties while preventing family resilience from justifying the transfer of economic risk to wives. Its implementation requires further legal development.
Public Oversight as a Form of Citizen Participation in the Governance of the Daya Anagata Nusantara Investment Management Agency from a Good Governance Perspective
1237-1248
One of the goals of the Indonesian state is to advance public welfare as stated in the Preamble to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Paragraph 4. In order to realize this national goal, a national fiscal policy is necessary. One of the fiscal policies used by Indonesia is the establishment of Daya Anagata Nusantara (Danantara) as a superholding of State-Owned Enterprises. The implementation of Danantara as a superholding must be in accordance with laws and regulations and the General Principles of Good Governance as an implementation of the concept of a state based on law (rechtstaat). The implementation of Danantara with the provided capital almost reaching ⅓ of the total 2026 State Revenue and Expenditure Budget, of course, must be accompanied by ideal supervision and public participation as referring to the concept of a state based on law. In addition, with the absence of the role of the DPR and DPD in the administration of the state, the implementation of Danantara is not transparent and does not fulfill the principle of openness as stipulated in Article 10 Paragraph (1) letter f of Law 30/2014. A government that is not based on AUPB is a government that tends to violate the rights of citizens and does not implement good governance.
Allocation of Liability for Cargo Damage during Carriage by Sea Using Shipper-Owned Containers
994-1015
The carriage of goods by sea plays an important role in supporting trade and economic activities, particularly in Indonesia as an archipelagic state. In modern maritime transportation, the use of Shipper-Owned Containers (SOC) raises legal issues concerning the allocation of liability for cargo damage, as the container is owned by the shipper while the transportation is carried out by the carrier. This issue becomes more complex due to the absence of specific regulations governing SOC under Indonesian positive law. This research aims to analyze the legal position of SOC in the carriage of goods by sea and the allocation of liability between carriers and shippers for cargo damage. This research employs a normative juridical method using statutory and conceptual approaches, analyzed descriptively and analytically. The results indicate that SOC ownership places responsibility for the maintenance and fitness of the container upon the shipper, while the carrier remains principally responsible for the safety and security of the cargo during transportation. The allocation of liability is determined based on the cause of the damage, the obligations of each party, and the causal relationship between fault and loss. The applicable principle is presumption of liability, under which the carrier may be released from liability if it can prove that the loss was not caused by its fault.
Building a Harmonious Family: Quraish Shihab's Interpretation of Surah Ar-Rum (30:21) and Its Normative Relevance to Contemporary Family Resilience
1378-1387
This article examines M. Quraish Shihab's interpretation of Surah Ar-Rum (30:21) and its normative relevance to contemporary family resilience. It employs library research and a contextual tafsir analysis informed by socio-psychological concepts rather than empirical family-psychology research. The primary text is volume 11 of Tafsir Al-Mishbah, especially the commentary on Surah Ar-Rum (30:21), with Wahbah al-Zuḥaylī's Tafsir Al-Munir used as a bounded comparator. Twenty-one secondary works in the original corpus were re-screened for thematic relevance, traceable metadata, and analytical proximity; seventeen were retained, while primary and official legal-administrative materials were added. The coding matrix covered five categories: sakinah, mawaddah, raḥmah, relational mechanisms, and spiritual meaning-making. The findings show that Shihab presents sakinah as tranquillity compatible with relational dynamics, while mawaddah and raḥmah describe affective and compassionate qualities that sustain marriage. The distinction between khalaqa and jaʿala is treated cautiously: the proposition that affection must be cultivated is the authors' contextual synthesis, not a verbatim claim by Shihab. The phrase min anfusikum supports a shared human origin but does not, by itself, determine the legal distribution of marital rights and duties. Normatively, the interpretation resonates with Article 3 of Indonesia's Compilation of Islamic Law and may enrich existing premarital-guidance materials, although its practical effectiveness remains an empirical question.
Community Service Sentencing as an Alternative to Short-Term Imprisonment Under Indonesia’s National Criminal Code
1537-1548
Community service constitutes a principal punishment under Indonesia’s National Criminal Code and, within the statutory conditions of Article 85, offers an alternative to short custodial sentences or specified fines. This article examines the legal criteria for imposing community service and the institutional conditions for its implementation. Using normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches, it distinguishes the applicable legal framework from proposals that still require institutional agreements or technical standards. Since Law Number 1 of 2023 entered into force on 2 January 2026, the analysis treats community service as part of the operative sentencing framework rather than an indefinitely prospective policy. Eligibility requires both an offense punishable by imprisonment of less than five years and a judicial decision that would otherwise impose no more than six months’ imprisonment or a fine up to category II. The defendant’s informed agreement, ability to work, safety, social circumstances and other statutory considerations shape judicial discretion. The punishment ranges from eight to 240 hours, may not be commercialized, and is subject to prosecutor supervision and guidance by community corrections officers. The article proposes a coordinated implementation and evaluation model while acknowledging that it has not empirically measured readiness, prison-population changes or recidivism outcomes.
Restorative-Justice-Based Handling of Electronic Defamation Offences at Barru District Police
1800-1813
This normative-empirical study examines the handling of alleged electronic defamation through restorative justice at the Barru District Police. It distinguishes the substantive requirements of the applicable offence from the procedural requirements of Police Regulation No. 8 of 2021, and considers investigator accounts alongside limitations of the available case documentation. The reported aggregate of 39 cases and 14 restorative settlements cannot, without case-level records, establish the legality or effectiveness of every resolution. The study identifies the need for documented voluntary consent, restoration of victims’ rights, formal review of eligibility, and written decisions on termination. Social pressure, refusal to settle, and gaps in accessible records are treated as issues for safeguarding due process, not proof of institutional failure.
Due Diligence and Directors’ Liability for Startup Investment Losses: Evaluating the Business Judgment Rule in Indonesian Venture Capital Companies
2099-2107
This doctrinal study examines the evidentiary relevance of due diligence when assessing the liability of venture-capital directors for startup investment losses under the business judgment rule. Using statutory and conceptual approaches, it differentiates equity investment from financing and identifies proportionate standards of pre-investment verification. An investment loss alone does not establish negligent management, while the mere existence of a due-diligence report does not automatically protect directors. The proposed ex ante assessment links information available at the decision date, material red flags, independent verification, documented board responses, conflicts of interest, and causal relationships to the loss. It also distinguishes corporate liability under Article 97 of the Limited Liability Company Law from separate criminal-law questions.
A Normative Legal Analysis of the Effectiveness of Law Enforcement in Securing National Vital Objects in Ambon City
645-668
This article examines law-enforcement effectiveness in securing National Vital Objects in Ambon City through allocation of institutional responsibility, risk-based security, operational capacity, and the limits of drawing empirical effectiveness conclusions from normative legal research. It uses normative legal research and a structured analysis of applicable legal materials, supported by comparative and interdisciplinary scholarship where relevant. The revised analysis distinguishes legal design from empirical claims and identifies the principal regulatory or institutional gap. The study finds that existing law provides important but fragmented safeguards and that legal certainty depends on clearer decision criteria, procedural accountability, and proportionate remedies. It proposes an operational framework that specifies legal thresholds, institutional responsibilities, safeguards, and review mechanisms. The article contributes a more explicit research gap, a reproducible doctrinal method, and a policy model calibrated to legality, proportionality, accountability, and rights protection.
The Juridical Recognition and Implementation of Living Law Decisions by State Courts in Indonesia
765-787
This article looks at how living law, customary criminal law fits into Indonesias national criminal law system. The main question is how to include criminal law without hurting the principles of legality, legal certainty and constitutional protections. A normative juridical method is used, which involves analyzing laws and court decisions. The analysis includes The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Emergency Law Number 1 of 1951, Law Number 48 of 2009 on Judicial Power, Law Number 1 of 2023 on the National Criminal Code, Relevant court decisions, The study finds that customary criminal law is a source of unwritten law. It is recognized when it reflects norms that're still alive accepted and obeyed by customary communities. However its use must align with Pancasila, human rights, proportionality and the rule of law. Judges play a role in deciding if customary settlements can affect prosecution, sentencing or preventing double punishment. at the end living law that comes from indigenous peoples should be seen as a controlled expansion of law sources, guided by the constitution. The integration of criminal law requires careful consideration to ensure it works with the existing legal system. This means balancing law with national laws and constitutional protections. The role of judges is crucial, in making this balance work.
The Role of the Police in Addressing Narcotic Use Among Minors at the Investigation Stage: A Study of the Medan City Metropolitan Police (Polrestabes)
1102-1119
This empirical legal research aims to determine and analyze the role of the Police apparatus at the investigation level at the Medan City Police (Polrestabes Medan) in overcoming the criminal act of narcotics use by minors, as well as to identify the obstacle factors encountered. The research method used is empirical legal research with a socio-legal approach and a case approach, which is analyzed qualitatively using deductive reasoning. The results indicate that police investigators face a dilemma in harmonizing the application of Law Number 35 of 2009 concerning Narcotics, which is repressive in nature, with Law Number 11 of 2012 concerning the Juvenile Criminal Justice System (UU SPPA), which promotes restorative justice principles and diversion mechanisms. In practice, these prevention efforts are hindered by three main factors: (1) legal substance obstacles in the form of normative conflicts and investigators being constrained by weight limits based on Supreme Court Circular (SEMA) No. 4 of 2010, which complicates the implementation of diversion for children manipulated as couriers; (2) legal structure obstacles due to the lack of Special Service Rooms (RPK) and Social Welfare Institutions (LPKS) facilities in the Medan area; and (3) legal culture obstacles including the slow issuance of community research reports (Litmas) by Bapas, family fear of social stigma, and community rejection of non-judicial settlement mechanisms.
Notary Websites: Distinguishing Information From Promotion Under Article 4 Point 3 of the Code of Ethics
1469-1482
Digital legal services increasingly encourage notaries to use websites and social media to expand public access to legal information. Article 4 point 3 of the Indonesian Notary Code of Ethics, however, prohibits self-publication and promotion through printed or electronic media without providing operational criteria that clearly distinguish permissible information from prohibited promotion. This study examines that normative boundary and formulates practical parameters for notaries, the Honorary Council, and supervisory bodies. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and limited comparative approaches. The study finds that the legal assessment should not turn on the mere existence of a website. Instead, it should examine the purpose of the content, substantive presentation, language, price disclosure, transactional calls to action, testimonials, comparative claims, and mechanisms for soliciting prospective clients. Educational, neutral, non-commercial content that is not designed to acquire clients may be treated as professional information, whereas persuasive content that highlights superiority, offers prices or packages, displays testimonials, or directly solicits clients is more properly categorized as promotion. The article proposes technical guidance by the Indonesian Notary Association containing measurable indicators, an explicit exception for non-commercial legal education, standardized oversight, and safeguards for personal data processed through digital contact channels.
An Analysis of Judges’ Considerations in Granting Marriage Dispensation at the Purwodadi Religious Court from a Gender Justice Perspective
1728-1743
This study aims to analyze judicial considerations in granting marriage dispensation applications at the Purwodadi Religious Court from a gender justice perspective. The study employs a normative legal approach by examining relevant legislation and court decisions. The objects of the study are Decision Number 910/Pdt.P/2023/PA.Pwd and Decision Number 902/Pdt.P/2023/PA.Pwd, both concerning marriage dispensation applications related to pregnancy outside marriage. The findings reveal differences in the emphasis placed on legal considerations in the two decisions. Decision Number 910/Pdt.P/2023/PA.Pwd places greater emphasis on judicial prudence, family preparedness, parental responsibility, and the assessment of evidence. Meanwhile, Decision Number 902/Pdt.P/2023/PA.Pwd focuses more on the factual circumstances of the parties, pregnancy, and considerations of public benefit to prevent greater harm. From a gender justice perspective, pregnancy outside marriage should not automatically justify marriage without a comprehensive assessment of psychological readiness, health, continuity of education, freedom of consent, and the best interests of the child. This study emphasizes that granting marriage dispensation requires careful legal consideration, sufficient supporting evidence, and a commitment to child protection and gender justice. Accordingly, marriage dispensation should remain an exceptional legal measure granted on the basis of compelling reasons, adequate evidence, and substantive protection of children's rights.
Implementation of Local Finance Laws in the Management of the Regional Budget for Poverty Alleviation in Tidore Kepulauan City
2056-2070
This study aims to analyze the implementation of local finance laws in the management of the Tidore Kepulauan City Regional Budget in efforts to alleviate poverty, as well as to identify the normative and empirical barriers that affect its effectiveness. This study employs a socio-legal approach, using data collection techniques such as literature review, interviews, observation, and documentation. Data analysis was conducted qualitatively using welfare state theory, public finance theory, and good governance theory. The results indicate that the implementation of regional financial laws in the management of the Regional Budget has proceeded in accordance with the applicable normative framework through the stages of planning, budgeting, implementation, and oversight. However, substantively, its effectiveness remains suboptimal. This is due to several factors, including limited local fiscal capacity, the dominance of personnel expenditures, weak planning based on poverty data, low community participation, and oversight that remains administratively oriented. Additionally, there is a gap between legal norms and practice, where the orientation of Regional Budget management places greater emphasis on procedural compliance rather than achieving results that directly impact poverty reduction. The implications of this study underscore that strengthening the implementation of local financial laws requires a reorientation toward performance-based budget policies, improved data-driven planning, and the reinforcement of good governance principles throughout the entire Regional Budget cycle.
Legal Analysis of the Surakarta City Government's Tourism Policy in Realizing Inclusive Tourism
567-584
This study analyses the coherence of Surakarta City’s legal framework for inclusive tourism, with an operational focus on accessibility for persons with disabilities because this dimension is supported by the clearest enforceable legal duties. The research is normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and limited comparative approaches. The principal legal materials include Law Number 10 of 2009 on Tourism, Law Number 8 of 2016 on Persons with Disabilities, Surakarta City Regulation Number 13 of 2016, Surakarta City Regulation Number 5 of 2017, Surakarta City Regulation Number 9 of 2020, and Surakarta Mayor Regulations Number 26 and Number 27 of 2024. The analysis shows that Surakarta does not face a complete regulatory vacuum: tourism regulations, disability-rights rules, tourism-area service standards, and general sanctioning mechanisms already exist. The central normative problem is fragmentation and the incomplete integration of accessibility standards with tourism-business obligations, service indicators, supervision, licensing, and cross-agency coordination. Friedman’s legal-system theory is used to assess the normative design of legal substance and legal structure, while legal culture is treated as an empirical research agenda that is not measured by this study. The article recommends harmonising existing instruments, developing measurable accessibility indicators and procedures, and strengthening coordination through a mechanism that does not duplicate the disability institutions already established.
Owner Dominance, Conflicts of Interest, and Credit Governance in Regional Government Owned BPR: An Assessment of POJK Number 9 of 2024 Through the Bank Daerah Lamongan Case
874-894
This article examines how local-government ownership of BPR Perseroda may create governance risks in credit decision-making and assesses whether the current regulatory architecture provides adequate safeguards against conflicts of interest and informal owner influence. Bank Daerah Lamongan (BDL) is used only as a case illustration, not as proof of shareholder intervention or of a causal relationship between ownership and non-performing loans. Using normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches, the study reads POJK Number 9 of 2024 together with related rules on anti-fraud, AML/CFT, maximum lending limits, related-party transactions, risk management, compliance, and internal audit. The analysis distinguishes formal independence from substantive independence and develops operational indicators such as approval override, undocumented instructions, failure to abstain, retaliation, exceptions from credit policy, and weaknesses in audit trails. The study finds that the main normative gap lies not in the absence of governance duties, but in the evidentiary and procedural mechanisms needed to detect and respond to informal influence. It recommends proportionate communication logs, conflict screening, independent review, protected reporting, and supervisory access to relevant records. The study does not assess actual BDL loan files, supervisory findings, or the legality of any individual credit decision.
The Role of the North Sumatra Provincial National Narcotics Agency in Preventing the Abuse of Narcotic-Laced Vape Liquid Among the Residents of Medan City
1045-1062
This study analyzes the role of the North Sumatra Provincial National Narcotics Agency (BNNP Sumut) in preventing the abuse of narcotic-laced vape liquids in Medan City. The inquiry is deliberately framed around role implementation and process adequacy rather than behavioral outcome effectiveness, which would require population-level measurement. The study uses an empirical legal approach combining statutory analysis, semi-structured interviews with two purposively selected BNNP Sumut informants in July 2026, and documentary triangulation using official and institutional sources. Implementation adequacy is assessed through five benchmarks: consistency with the legal mandate, specificity of risk communication, documented program delivery, readiness for inter-agency and laboratory coordination, and monitoring and evaluation records. The findings indicate that BNNP Sumut performs preventive functions through communication, information, education, community empowerment, and inter-agency coordination. The available evidence, however, is insufficient to attribute any reduction in drug abuse directly to those programs. Principal constraints include the adaptation of drug delivery through vape products, the need for laboratory testing to identify controlled substances, distribution through digital and informal channels, and limited outcome-based documentation. Stronger prevention therefore requires laboratory and early-detection coordination, legally grounded digital-market monitoring, youth-specific vape-risk education, and traceable evaluation indicators.
Criminal Sanction Disparity Between Marriage-Impediment Offences and Cohabitation under Indonesia's New Criminal Code: A Comparative Study of Muslim-Majority Jurisdictions
1402-1417
This article examines the disparity between the penalties for marriage-impediment offences under Article 402 and cohabitation under Article 412 of Indonesia's Law Number 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code. It rejects the shorthand description of Article 402 as an "unauthorized polygamy offence" because criminal liability requires an existing marriage that constitutes a lawful impediment, the offender's knowledge of that impediment, and, in the aggravated form, concealment of it from the other party. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and functional-comparative approaches, the study compares Indonesia with Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, the Federal Territories of Malaysia, Pakistan, and Iran through common variables: prior authorization for plural marriage, consequences of non-compliance, the type of non-marital intimate conduct criminalized, prosecution triggers, penalty ranges, protected legal interests, and victim protection. The comparison shows that penalty differences partly reflect distinct protected interests and degrees of culpability, but problems of fair labelling, certainty of offence elements, and proportionality remain. Reform should clarify criminal elements through legislation or lawful judicial interpretation, distinguish the legal complaint required for Article 412 from the provision of information to authorities, avoid compulsory mediation, and strengthen family-law remedies without expanding criminal offences through subordinate regulation.
A Mudharabah Perspective on the Application of the Business Judgment Rule to the Liability of State-Owned Enterprise Directors (A Study of Ira Puspadewi's Rehabilitation)
1633-1648
This article examines the business judgment rule (BJR) in the liability of Indonesian state-owned enterprise directors through PT ASDP Indonesia Ferry’s acquisition of PT Jembatan Nusantara. It also examines mudharabah and the presidential rehabilitation of Ira Puspadewi. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, the study finds that BJR protection requires cumulative proof of absence of fault, good-faith and careful management, freedom from conflicts of interest, and loss-prevention measures. The dissent on due care does not displace the majority’s contrary assessment of abuse of authority. The mudharabah analogy distinguishes normal commercial loss from loss arising from transgression, negligence, or breach of trust, without equating SOE governance with that contract. Presidential rehabilitation is assessed as a separate constitutional act. The article proposes clearer evidentiary standards for directors’ liability.
Progressive Legal Reasoning in Judicial Perspectives on Interfaith Inheritance: A Socio-Legal Study at the Class IA Makassar Religious Court
1960-1982
This article examines four reported judicial perspectives at the Class IA Makassar Religious Court on progressive legal reasoning (hukum progresif) in interfaith inheritance and the possible use of a mandatory bequest (wasiat wajibah) for non-Muslim relatives. The qualitative socio-legal approach relies on interview summaries reported in the authors’ underlying manuscript—not independently audited transcripts—and a doctrinal reading of the Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI), legislation on judicial authority, and six Supreme Court decisions discussed in the official jurisprudence digest through 2018. The reported judges support fact-sensitive justice within jurisdictional and legal constraints, but differ in their emphases. A non-Muslim family member does not automatically acquire the status of an Islamic heir under Article 171(c) KHI; receiving a mandatory bequest is a distinct juridical route. Its extension beyond adoptive relationships arises from jurisprudential development, not the express wording of Article 209 KHI. The cases show differing beneficiary categories and reported allocations, while several precise holdings and denominators remain unascertainable without full judgments. The article proposes a sequential test of jurisdiction, family evidence, marital-property separation, bequest limits, and protection of recognised heirs. Interview statements are not presented as proof of how the six Supreme Court cases were decided.
Freedom of Expression and Electronic Defamation on Social Media: A Juridical Analysis of the Haris Azhar and Fatia Maulidiyanti Decisions
669-686
The expansion of social media as a forum for public criticism has intensified the legal tension between freedom of expression and protection of reputation in Indonesia. This study analyses the acquittals of Haris Azhar and Fatia Maulidiyanti by the East Jakarta District Court, the subsequent rejection of the prosecutor's cassation by the Supreme Court, and the relevance of recent changes to Indonesia's electronic information law. The study applies normative juridical research using statutory, case, conceptual, and comparative approaches. Primary legal materials include the 1945 Constitution, Law Number 19 of 2016, Law Number 1 of 2024, the district court and Supreme Court decisions, and Constitutional Court Decision Number 105/PUU-XXII/2024. Secondary materials include Indonesian legal scholarship and five recent Elsevier journal articles on digital speech, platform governance, content moderation, and chilling effects. The analysis finds that the judicial reasoning draws a legally significant distinction between criticism directed at public policy or public office and attacks on personal honour. The Supreme Court's cassation ruling strengthens that distinction as persuasive jurisprudence, although Indonesia does not apply stare decisis. The 2024 statutory amendment and the Constitutional Court's 2025 interpretation further narrow the legitimate reach of electronic defamation law. The study argues that restrictions on online expression should focus on demonstrable attacks on individual reputation and should not convert research-based public-interest criticism into criminal defamation. This approach provides a more coherent balance between constitutional expression, reputation, legal certainty, and democratic oversight.
Reconstructing the Legal Policy of Human Resource Management in Indonesian State-Owned Enterprises after the 2025 SOE Law Reforms: An Accountability-Based Corporate Merit Model
1025-1044
Reforming human resource management in Indonesian State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) is a matter of legal policy because the state must reconcile its authority as owner, the demands of public accountability, and the need for corporate autonomy. This study analyzes the direction of legal policy governing SOE human resources following the 2025 reforms to the SOE legal regime, identifies normative fragmentation and the risks of non-professional intervention, and formulates a governance model compatible with the corporate character of SOEs. The study employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and historical approaches. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively and prescriptively through the inventory of norms, systematic and teleological interpretation, and consistency testing across the SOE, company, labor, corporate-governance, and merit regimes. The findings show that the civil-service merit system should not be transplanted directly into SOEs because of differences in employment status, authority structures, and business requirements. The novelty of this study lies in the construction of accountability-based corporate merit as a legal-policy model built on five pillars: regulatory coherence, professional independence, competency- and performance-based objectivity, decision traceability, and proportional accountability. Under this model, law functions as an accountability boundary for corporate discretion rather than as an instrument of uniformity, thereby preserving professionalism and business flexibility without diminishing transparency, integrity, or public accountability.
Zakat on Crypto Assets in Indonesia: Contemporary Fiqh, Post-P2SK Regulation, and a Governance Proposal for BAZNAS
1367-1377
This article examines zakat on crypto assets in Indonesia by separating three questions that are often conflated: recognition under positive law, characterization as property (māliyyah) in Islamic jurisprudence, and the operational design of zakat administration. The study uses doctrinal legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches. The source corpus was updated through 30 September 2026 and gives priority to primary materials: the P2SK Law, OJK regulations, the OJK-Bank Indonesia-Bappebti transfer documents, tax regulations, official decisions or fatwas of MUI, Muhammadiyah, Nahdlatul Ulama, the Perlis State Fatwa Committee, and Egypt's Dar al-Ifta, together with BAZNAS policy documents. The analysis shows that the transfer of digital-financial-asset supervision to OJK does not itself establish a Sharia characterization of crypto as māl. Fatwa positions are also non-uniform: some conditionally recognize crypto assets, while others prohibit specified forms of dealing. The article therefore rejects a universal 2.5 percent formula for every crypto position. Active trading inventory, long-term holdings, stablecoins, and staking rewards require separate analysis of ownership intention, asset characteristics, source of returns, niṣāb, and ḥawl. It proposes “Zakat 4.0” as an author-developed governance model, not an existing nationwide BAZNAS system, emphasizing OJK-licensed intermediaries, KYC/AML-CFT controls, valuation rules, rupiah conversion, custody safeguards, auditability, and Sharia governance. Zakat and tax are treated as distinct obligations; the gross-income deduction follows PP 60/2010 and PMK 254/2010.
Special Protection for Children with Disabilities as Victims of Sexual Offenses: A Study of the Parepare Police Women and Children’s Service Unit
1549-1562
Children with disabilities who become victims of sexual offenses may face communication, evidentiary and service-access barriers during police investigation. This article examines protective measures reported by the Women and Children’s Service Unit at Parepare Police and obstacles to their implementation. The study combines police interview material and an aggregate case summary with analysis of child-protection, disability and sexual-violence legislation. The administrative summary records eight cases involving children with intellectual disabilities: two in 2024, five in 2025 and one in a partial 2026 record. Reported measures include family or guardian accompaniment, psychological and social-work support, identity protection and interagency coordination. The analysis distinguishes the presence of an accompanying person from provision of individualized accommodation, and procedural progress from fulfillment of victim rights. Case counts do not establish prevalence or service effectiveness, and the 2026 record does not represent a complete year. The principal reported obstacles concern specialists, facilities and coordination. The article develops a sequence for needs assessment, accessible communication, verified referrals, information protection and service monitoring. It concludes that protective activity is reported, while consistency and adequacy require case-level evidence of participation, access and recovery.
The Urgency of Strengthening the Legal Foundation of the Free Nutritious Meal Program: Legal Certainty and Governance Perspectives
1814-1831
The Free Nutritious Meals (MBG) Program is a strategic government policy aimed at improving nutritional quality, particularly among children and vulnerable groups, while strengthening family resilience. However, its implementation requires a strong legal foundation to ensure legal certainty, effective governance, and program sustainability. This study aims to analyze the urgency of establishing a legal basis for the implementation of the MBG Program. The research employs a normative legal method using a statutory approach and a conceptual approach. Legal materials were collected through a literature review, covering relevant legislation and scientific literature, and analyzed using a descriptive qualitative method. The findings indicate that a legal foundation plays a crucial role in legitimizing government policy, ensuring legal certainty, clarifying the division of authority among institutions, and strengthening transparency and accountability in the use of state funds. Presidential Regulation No. 83 of 2024 concerning the National Nutrition Agency provides the institutional foundation, while Presidential Regulation No. 115 of 2025 concerning the Governance of the Free Nutritious Meals Program regulates its implementation. Furthermore, a clear legal framework is essential to protecting the public's right to adequate health and nutrition and minimizing the risks of budgetary irregularities and inaccurate beneficiary targeting. Therefore, regulatory harmonization, the development of technical regulations, and strengthened oversight are essential to ensuring that the MBG Program is implemented effectively, accountably, and sustainably.
Reassessing Collateral Residuary Inheritance in Indonesia through Al-Sarakhsī’s Al-Mabsūṭ and Supreme Court Jurisprudence
2108-2118
This study examines collateral residuary inheritance by comparing al-Sarakhsī’s discussion in Al-Mabsūṭ with the Compilation of Islamic Law and literature on Indonesian Supreme Court decisions. It uses doctrinal research combining conceptual and statutory analysis with a limited examination of judicial materials. The analysis distinguishes kinship-based entitlement, the interpretation of walad as including daughters, and the authors’ proposal to consider care and financial contributions. The cited classical passages do not establish actual economic support as a general condition of residuary entitlement. Judicial literature indicates that the interpretation of walad may affect the position of the deceased’s siblings, but does not demonstrate a general contribution-based rule. The article proposes a conditional and proportionate model for legislative debate, subject to a clear legal basis, protection of fixed shares, and defined evidentiary safeguards. Social contribution alone does not authorize the cancellation of an inheritance entitlement under existing law.
Sentencing Narcotics Users through Integrated Assessment Based Rehabilitative Diversion after the National Criminal Code and the Criminal Provisions Adjustment Law
687-700
This article examines integrated-assessment-based rehabilitative diversion for narcotics users through proportional sentencing, differentiation of personal users from traffickers, recovery-oriented sanctions, and safeguards against misuse of diversion. It uses normative legal research and a structured analysis of applicable legal materials, supported by comparative and interdisciplinary scholarship where relevant. The revised analysis distinguishes legal design from empirical claims and identifies the principal regulatory or institutional gap. The study finds that existing law provides important but fragmented safeguards and that legal certainty depends on clearer decision criteria, procedural accountability, and proportionate remedies. It proposes an operational framework that specifies legal thresholds, institutional responsibilities, safeguards, and review mechanisms. The article contributes a more explicit research gap, a reproducible doctrinal method, and a policy model calibrated to legality, proportionality, accountability, and rights protection.
Child Sexual Violence from the Perspective of Tolaki Customary Law in Kolaka Regency
895-907
This study examines the position of child sexual violence within the perspective of Tolaki customary law in Kolaka Regency, given that the existing literature on Tolaki customary law predominantly addresses moral customary offenses in the context of adultery (umoapi) between adults, while regulations explicitly addressing child sexual violence remain understudied. This research employs a normative-juridical method using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, drawing on primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials. The findings indicate that child sexual violence under Tolaki customary law falls within the general category of moral customary offenses and may be subject to the peohala sanction in the form of customary fines; however, such customary resolution cannot substitute the national criminal justice process, as child sexual violence constitutes a public offense (delicta publica) whose prosecution remains within the domain of the state. Customary mechanisms may function complementarily as a means of psychosocial recovery for victims through a restorative justice approach, provided they operate alongside, rather than in place of, the criminal justice process. This study recommends strengthening regional legal frameworks and formal cooperation protocols among customary institutions, relevant government agencies, the police, and the prosecutor's office in Kolaka Regency, so that customary resolution is not misused to shield perpetrators from criminal accountability.
The Effectiveness of Law Enforcement Against Street Crime by the Medan City Resort Police (Polrestabes Medan)
1131-1142
This study assesses the effectiveness of law-enforcement efforts against street crime by the Medan City Police (Polrestabes Medan) and identifies internal and external factors affecting implementation. It employs a socio-legal (empirical-juridical) method based on purposive interviews with three Polrestabes Medan officers conducted on 13–14 March 2026, a literature review, and analysis of the manuscript's street-crime report data for 2021–2025. Effectiveness is operationalized through Soerjono Soekanto's legal-effectiveness factors and the available indicators concerning legal basis, patrol implementation, personnel and facilities, community participation, and crime-report trends. The findings show that routine patrols and the JCS (Jaga, Cegah, Sigap or Guard, Prevent, Respond) program function as preventive instruments, but the available evidence is insufficient to establish that JCS itself caused a reduction in street crime because the program began only in December 2025 and no equivalent post-launch time series is available. Effectiveness is therefore assessed as partial and constrained by staffing, the need for stronger program evaluation, community participation, socioeconomic conditions, and narcotics abuse reported by police informants as one relevant risk factor. The study recommends measurable patrol standards, data-based crime mapping, stronger community-reporting mechanisms, and improved inter-functional and inter-agency coordination.
Interfaith Marriages Abroad: Civil Registration, Article 56 and the Limits of Fraus Legis
1483-1497
Interfaith marriages solemnized abroad raise legal problems at the intersection of marriage law, population administration, and private international law. This study examines the authority of the Population and Civil Registration Office (Disdukcapil) to receive reports of overseas marriages, assesses the use of Article 56 of the Marriage Law as a basis for administrative recognition, and identifies circumstances in which the deliberate choice of a foreign jurisdiction may amount to legal evasion or fraus legis. The study uses normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. It finds that civil registration is principally administrative and declaratory and therefore does not itself validate the marriage materially under religious law. Nevertheless, the validity of an overseas marriage involving Indonesian citizens remains limited by the statutory requirement that it must not violate the Indonesian Marriage Law. The deliberate transfer of a connecting factor to a foreign jurisdiction may indicate fraus legis when it is intended to avoid mandatory national rules and lacks a genuine connection with the chosen jurisdiction. The unresolved relationship between administrative registration and substantive validity creates potential cancellation risks and legal uncertainty for spouses, children, and good-faith third parties. The article recommends statutory harmonization, clearer indicators of legal evasion, consistent document verification, and stronger protection of children’s civil rights.
Distributive Accountability in the Allocation of Music Royalties: A Comparative Legal Study of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand
1983-2017
The debate on music royalty management in Indonesia has centred on which institution may collect royalties, whereas whether royalties paid by users actually reach right holders has received far less attention. This prescriptive normative legal research introduces the concept of distributive accountability, namely the duty of every party holding royalties to account, in an enforceable manner, for each portion of those royalties to the right holder entitled to it. Employing statutory, functional-comparative, and conceptual approaches, the study examines Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand across seven links of the distribution chain: the status of the funds, usage data, the allocation key, deductions, deadlines and individual information, unidentified royalties, and redress. None of the three systems has a complete chain. Malaysia’s strength in force is a statutory Copyright Tribunal, while its 2025 distribution guidelines are currently stayed by the courts. Thailand creates traceability at the point of collection but does not regulate distribution by statute. Indonesia has usage-based distribution and an annual public audit, yet its allocation key is determinate at only one of three stages, its deductions stack without a cumulative cap, right holders receive no individual distribution statements, and unrecorded royalties may become reserve funds. The article proposes a distributive accountability model resting on five principles: funds held for the benefit of right holders; traceability and proportionality to use; legality and reasonableness of deductions; timeliness and individual transparency; and claims that survive reallocation, with enforceable redress, implemented in stages according to the hierarchy of laws and regulations.
Reinterpreting Kafa’ah through Maqasid al-Shari’ah: Marriage Compatibility in an Era of Social Disruption
1949-1959
Contemporary changes in family formation raise questions about the role of kafa’ah (marital compatibility) in Islamic jurisprudence. This normative literature study compares historical compatibility considerations across juristic traditions and proposes a maqasid-based evaluative framework for present-day decisions. Its approach is conceptual rather than an empirical assessment of divorce or family outcomes. The analysis distinguishes religious eligibility and free consent from social criteria such as lineage, occupation and wealth, whose legal treatment differs among schools. It proposes a functional test centred on informed consent, ethical and religious commitments, the prevention of harm, shared decision-making, and demonstrable economic responsibility. These criteria are related to the protection of religion, life, intellect, lineage and property without presenting them as statutory marriage-validity requirements. The Indonesian Compilation of Islamic Law already limits objections based solely on a perceived mismatch, subject to religious difference. The proposed model therefore primarily informs legal interpretation and premarital counselling; any wider legislative reform or claim of improved family outcomes requires separate evidence.
Women’s Inheritance Rights in a Patrilineal Customary System: A Juridical Analysis of Supreme Court Decision Number 1130 K/Pdt/2017
583-599
Supreme Court Decision Number 1130 K/Pdt/2017 represents an important point in resolving the tension between the patrilineal customary law of the Manggarai community and the principle of equality in Indonesian national law. This study aims to analyse the position of patrilineal customary law within the national legal system, women’s inheritance rights from the perspectives of jurisprudence and human rights, and the judges’ reasoning in correcting custom-based discrimination. The method employed is normative juridical research using statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. Primary legal materials comprise Supreme Court Decision Number 1130 K/Pdt/2017, the 1945 Constitution, Law Number 39 of 1999 concerning Human Rights, and related jurisprudence, while secondary legal materials consist of legal literature, scholarly journals, and books. Data were collected through library research, and analysed using legal interpretation and legal argumentation. The findings show that patrilineal customary law which does not recognise women’s inheritance rights is deemed contrary to Article 27 of the 1945 Constitution and to Law Number 39 of 1999 concerning Human Rights. The Supreme Court has consistently continued the jurisprudence established since Decision Number 179 K/SIP/1961, which equated the inheritance rights of women and men. This study is not the first of its kind, but it offers an analytical contribution by reading the decision as a point at which three legal operations converge constitutional equality, the conditional recognition afforded by Article 18B paragraph (2), and the authority of Supreme Court jurisprudence and by separating the three in argumentative terms.
Legal Analysis of Sexual Intercourse with a Child Through Deceitful Means, a Series of Lies, or Persuasion: Case Study of Decision Number 70/Pid.Sus-Anak/2024/PN Mdn
815-827
Children receive special legal protection against sexual intercourse committed through deceitful means, a series of lies, or persuasion. This article analyses the offence elements, proof, and sentencing reasoning in Decision Number 70/Pid.Sus-Anak/2024/PN Mdn while distinguishing the legal positions of the child victim and juvenile offender. Using normative legal research with statutory and case approaches, it argues that consent or a dating relationship should not be generalised as negating liability where legislation protects children from specified means used to obtain intercourse; nevertheless, such facts must be placed accurately within proof of the charged elements. Deceitful means, a series of lies, and persuasion are alternative elements requiring objective differentiation. Medical evidence establishes clinical findings within its competence but does not by itself prove persuasion or deception. Because the study examines one decision, it does not claim a national pattern of adjudication.
Normative Gaps in the Protection of Mothers Caring for Children with Autism in the Special Region of Yogyakarta
1161-1182
The Special Region of Yogyakarta has a comparatively developed disability-law framework, yet its protection remains centred on children as rights-holders and does not recognize caregiving mothers as independent legal subjects with enforceable entitlements. This article examines a normative gap in the protection of mothers caring for children with autism: the absence of correlative rights for caregivers even though the law assigns them substantial caregiving duties. It is a normative legal study using statutory and conceptual approaches, supported by an illustrative case study in the Special Region of Yogyakarta. The materials comprise national and regional regulations, official data, one semi-structured in-depth interview with a caregiving mother, and publicly available parental testimonies used as supplementary documentation. Eva Feder Kittay’s ethics of care is employed as an evaluative lens for the distribution of care burdens, while correlative rights-and-duties analysis is used to test the legal structure. The findings distinguish implementation failure from a normative gap: children’s rights are formally recognized but are not always implemented, whereas caregivers’ independent rights to long-term support have not been formulated. The interview and media documentation illustrate economic dependency, labour-market exit, therapy costs, and the factual absorption of service gaps by families. The article recommends explicit recognition of caregivers in disability law, minimum support entitlements, gender-neutral caregiving leave, workplace flexibility, and coordination with social-security and child-protection regimes.
Reformulating Restorative Justice Authority under Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code
1450-1458
This article examines the allocation of restorative justice authority under Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP 2025) and formulates safeguards for coherent, voluntary, and reviewable implementation. Using normative legal research, it analyzes Articles 79–88 of KUHAP 2025, related police, prosecution, and Supreme Court regulations, the Sexual Violence Crime Law, and selected systematic reviews only as functional references for process risks and evaluation indicators. The study finds that KUHAP 2025 creates a statutory restorative-justice pathway across inquiry, investigation, prosecution, and trial, but coordination, consent verification, judicial scrutiny, data governance, and equality safeguards require more operational detail. It proposes an authority map, a minimum assessment form, a judicial-scrutiny standard, and monitoring indicators separated into outputs, outcomes, and safeguards. It also distinguishes short-term implementation through standard operating procedures and implementing regulations, medium-term harmonization of sectoral rules, and longer-term legislative refinement. The proposed model treats restorative justice as a rights-sensitive procedure rather than an informal shortcut to case disposal.
Harmonization of the Legal Framework for Hajj and Umrah Administration under Law Number 8 of 2019 and Law Number 14 of 2025
1617-1632
This doctrinal article compares Indonesia’s Law Number 8 of 2019 on Hajj and Umrah Administration with its third amendment, Law Number 14 of 2025. Through statutory and conceptual interpretation, it identifies amendments governing ministerial responsibility, allocation of Hajj quotas, adjustment of pilgrimage costs, supervision of special Hajj and Umrah operators, and the Ministry Information System. The amendment does not repeal the 2019 law in its entirety: provisions not amended remain in force. The article distinguishes statutory duties supported by specific provisions from proposed indicators concerning service standards, archiving, integrated digital governance, and pilgrim complaints. It argues for article-based implementation guidance, explicit coordination with the Hajj Financial Management Agency, traceable oversight decisions, and stronger accessible remedies for vulnerable pilgrims. Its contribution lies in a verifiable mapping of institutional responsibilities and legal consequences rather than an unsupported claim of wholesale replacement.
Reinterpretation of the Obligation of Marriage Registration Through the Concept of I‘lān al-Nikāḥ
1893-1915
This study examines the position of i‘lān al-nikāḥ in Islamic law and marriage registration in Indonesian positive law, their relationship, and the reinterpretation of the obligation of marriage registration through the maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah approach. Using a normative legal method with conceptual, philosophical, and statutory approaches, the study relies on library research and content analysis. The findings reveal that i‘lān al-nikāḥ emphasizes marital transparency and social recognition, while marriage registration provides official documentation, legal certainty, and protection of family rights. Although their legal functions differ, both share a common objective of ensuring openness and clarity in marital status. From the perspective of maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah, marriage registration supports the protection of lineage, dignity, and property, while preventing harm arising from uncertainty in family legal status. This study further finds that reinterpreting the obligation of marriage registration through the concept of i‘lān al-nikāḥ leads to a coherent interpretation of Article 2(1) and Article 2(2) as an integrated regulatory framework. Accordingly, marriage registration should be understood not merely as an administrative requirement but as an integral component of marriage regulation that ensures legal certainty and family protection, in line with the principle of openness embodied in i‘lān al-nikāḥ.
Legal Protection for Tourists as Accident Victims: Reconstructing the Liability of Tourism Operators in Indonesia
1352-1366
Documented accidents at tourism destinations illustrate the need for a legal framework that connects tourists' rights, operators' duties, safety standards, and effective remedies. This article examines legal protection for tourists who become accident victims and reconstructs the liability model for tourism destination operators. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and policy approaches; a case approach is not claimed because the manuscript does not establish a defined corpus of accident cases or judicial decisions. The analysis of Law No. 10 of 2009 as most recently amended by Law No. 18 of 2025 finds that Article 20 reformulates and expands tourist rights, Article 23 is deleted, while the operator duties in Article 26 remain central to safety and security. At the same time, changes to the sanction architecture and the absence of an integrated statutory mechanism for safety standards, victim compensation, and attribution of management failure justify further reconstruction. Administrative, civil, and criminal liability are treated as legal-consequence regimes, whereas corporate responsibility is treated as a subject-and-attribution dimension operating across those regimes. The proposed model integrates an Indonesian-law-based duty of care, operational indicators of management failure, risk governance, and clearer remedial pathways.
Legal Protection of Crypto Assets in Indonesia: A Comparative Analysis of the United States, Japan, and Singapore and Implications for Private Law
803-814
Advances in blockchain technology have given rise to various forms of digital assets, including crypto assets and tokenized assets representing particular rights and economic interests, thereby creating new challenges for Indonesia's civil-law system. This study examines whether Indonesian civil-law constructs can accommodate crypto-asset developments by comparing regulatory approaches in several jurisdictions. It employs normative legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches, supported by an analysis of legislation, doctrine, and legal literature. The findings show that the United States, Japan, and Singapore apply regulatory approaches based on the functions and economic characteristics of crypto assets, whereas Indonesia continues to regulate them only partially through Bappebti regulations and Law Number 4 of 2023 on Financial Sector Development and Strengthening, which focus on financial-sector supervision. Although Article 499 of the Indonesian Civil Code permits tokenized assets to be classified as intangible property, legal certainty is still lacking regarding their civil-law status, mechanisms for transferring rights, inheritance, and the protection of property rights. Accordingly, legislation at the level of an Act is needed to integrate civil law, financial-sector regulation, and the legal regimes governing underlying assets, thereby ensuring legal certainty while supporting digital-asset innovation in Indonesia.
Sexual Violence as a War Crime: The Binding Force of International Treaties and Their Enforcement
1016-1024
Sexual violence committed in armed conflict may constitute a war crime when a sufficient nexus to the armed conflict and the specific offense elements are established. In a distinct legal category, sexual violence may constitute a crime against humanity when it forms part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population and the perpetrator acts with the required knowledge. This normative legal study examines the binding force of international treaties, customary international law, and relevant enforcement mechanisms through the Geneva Conventions, the Additional Protocols, the Rome Statute, and international criminal jurisprudence. The study finds that offense classification must be clearly separated from jurisdiction. Treaty ratification is not the sole source of international obligation, but ICC jurisdiction does not arise automatically in relation to a non-party state. Effective enforcement therefore requires a combination of domestic implementing law, a valid jurisdictional basis, international cooperation, proof of contextual elements, and meaningful protection for victims.
Legal Comparison of Visa and Residence Permit Policies in Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia in Supporting the Business Climate in the ASEAN Region
1429-1449
Visa and residence permit policies are legal instruments of immigration governance that regulate the mobility of business actors, foreign workers, investors, and global talent while safeguarding state sovereignty and security. Within ASEAN, Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia have developed different policy designs to accommodate business and investment mobility. This study compares the legal frameworks governing visas and residence permits in the three countries, assesses their normative-administrative effectiveness in supporting the business climate, and formulates directions for Indonesian legal reform. It employs normative legal research using statutory, comparative, and conceptual approaches. Primary legal materials consist of immigration laws and policies of Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia, complemented by secondary legal materials and analyzed through a descriptive-comparative method. The analysis adopts the perspectives of ius constitutum, ius operatum, and ius constituendum. The study finds that Singapore operates a selective yet adaptive system through differentiated immigration pathways for investors and skilled professionals, supported by digitalized services and relatively clear institutional specialization. Malaysia relies on a pass-based regime and long-term residence programmes that are comparatively competitive for investors, professionals, and expatriates. Indonesia has undertaken reforms through visa simplification, digitalization, and the Golden Visa scheme, but still faces regulatory fragmentation, inter-agency coordination challenges, and the need for stronger legal certainty and service integration. Normatively, a simple, transparent, digital, and risk-based policy design is more compatible with business mobility while preserving immigration control. Indonesian reform should therefore focus on regulatory harmonization, institutional integration, service standards, and periodic evaluation of economic benefits and immigration risks.
Criminal Liability for Child Grooming in the Indonesian Criminal Law System: Normative Gaps and the Need for Harmonization
1649-1665
This article examines criminal liability for in-person and technology-mediated child grooming under Indonesian criminal law following the implementation of the 2023 Criminal Code in January 2026. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, it compares the elements of offences under the Child Protection Law, the Sexual Violence Crimes Law, the Pornography Law, the Electronic Information and Transactions framework, and the Criminal Code. The study finds that certain forms of solicitation, electronic sexual stalking, and involvement of children in pornography can already fall within existing offences; therefore, it is inaccurate to classify every preparatory stage of grooming as a legal vacuum. The narrower problem is the absence of a precisely defined, autonomous offence addressing a targeted, sexually motivated pattern of manipulation when no existing offence is established. Selected judicial decisions illuminate the treatment of power imbalance and purported child consent without proving that courts already criminalize the entire grooming process. The article proposes a carefully delimited conduct-based offence, requiring specific sexual intent, objectively demonstrable conduct, and rigorous evidentiary safeguards to avoid penalizing ordinary social interaction.
The Effectiveness of PERMA No. 1 of 2016 in Surabaya Religious Court Mediation, 2023–2025: A Legal-System Analysis
1832-1858
This study examines the effectiveness of Supreme Court Regulation (PERMA) No. 1 of 2016 on Court Mediation Procedures through the fluctuating mediation success rates across all case types at the Surabaya Religious Court from 2023 to 2025. It asks how mediation success fluctuated during this period and how the regulation’s effectiveness can be read through Lawrence M. Friedman’s legal system theory. This normative legal research employs statutory and conceptual approaches, treating the court’s annual activity reports as secondary legal materials analysed qualitatively and prescriptively. The findings show that the success rate moved from 45.10% (2023) to 93.16% (2024) before falling to 71.55% (2025), while mediation reached only 8.70–9.45% of the cases decided each year. In terms of legal substance, PERMA No. 1 of 2016 provides no standard operational definition or indicator of mediation success. In terms of legal structure, the court faces a shortage of judges, limited funding for external mediators, and inconsistent reporting. In terms of legal culture, an orientation toward numerical targets and performance awards risks displacing the meaning of substantive peace. The study recommends standardised success indicators that distinguish full settlement, partial agreement, and case withdrawal, so that mediation statistics can serve as a reliable measure of the regulation’s effectiveness.
Supervision and Protection of Non-Procedural Indonesian Migrant Workers from Ibn Taymiyyah’s Perspective
2119-2137
Non-procedural Indonesian migrant workers face heightened exposure to deceptive recruitment, exploitation, human trafficking, and barriers to effective legal remedies. This article examines the protection and supervision of such workers under Indonesian law and evaluates the relevance of Ibn Taymiyyah’s concepts of al-ḥisbah and al-siyāsah al-sharʿiyyah. Using normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches, it analyzes legislation, institutional regulations, scholarly literature, and official administrative data. The findings show that irregular departure does not extinguish fundamental rights or the statutory commitment to humane, non-discriminatory treatment; the principal deficiencies concern practical accessibility, interagency coordination, and early prevention. Institutional reforms and the revocation of several technical regulations in 2026 require careful clarification of implementing responsibilities. The article proposes a layered supervision model operating from villages and recruitment networks through immigration screening, consular assistance, and post-return remedies. Ibn Taymiyyah’s principles of public trust, justice, institutional competence, and prevention of oppression provide an ethical standard for evaluating this model. Recommended reforms include interoperable oversight, safe complaint pathways, accountable recruitment inspections, and accessible regular migration channels.
Legal Protection for Merchants against Automated Marketplace Decisions Reducing Rankings and Restricting Accounts
701-711
This article examines automated marketplace decisions that reduce product rankings or restrict merchant accounts through procedural fairness, explainability, human review, and legal remedies for merchants affected by automated platform governance. It uses normative legal research and a structured analysis of applicable legal materials, supported by comparative and interdisciplinary scholarship where relevant. The revised analysis distinguishes legal design from empirical claims and identifies the principal regulatory or institutional gap. The study finds that existing law provides important but fragmented safeguards and that legal certainty depends on clearer decision criteria, procedural accountability, and proportionate remedies. It proposes an operational framework that specifies legal thresholds, institutional responsibilities, safeguards, and review mechanisms. The article contributes a more explicit research gap, a reproducible doctrinal method, and a policy model calibrated to legality, proportionality, accountability, and rights protection.
The Normative Fragility of Women's Post-Divorce Economic Rights: Hierarchical Inversion between the Compilation of Islamic Law and Supreme Court Circular Letters from the Perspective of Hifz al-Mal
908-926
Hak ekonomi perempuan pasca-perceraian dalam perkara cerai gugat kerap tidak terwujud meskipun Mahkamah Agung telah menyediakan dasar aturannya. Penelitian yuridis normatif ini menggunakan pendekatan perundang-undangan, konseptual, dan kasus, dengan Putusan Pengadilan Agama Probolinggo Nomor 123/Pdt.G/2024/PA.Prob sebagai instansi pengujian, memadukan teori jenjang norma dan maqashid al-syari’ah, serta menganalisis bahan hukum secara kualitatif melalui penafsiran sistematis-teleologis dan analisis isi terhadap pertimbangan hukum putusan. Penelitian ini menemukan empat hal. Pertama, terjadi inversi hierarki. Norma yang meniadakan hak berbentuk pasal Kompilasi Hukum Islam yang bekerja otomatis, sedangkan norma yang memulihkannya berbentuk rumusan kamar agama dalam Surat Edaran Mahkamah Agung yang fakultatif. Kedua, terdapat kontradiksi kelembagaan, karena Mahkamah Agung sendiri menegaskan bahwa peraturan kebijakan tidak dapat diuji hakim, sementara hak substantif perempuan justru diletakkan pada instrumen berjenis peraturan kebijakan. Ketiga, terdapat ketidaksesuaian materi muatan, yakni substansi hukum materiil diangkut oleh wadah yang dirancang untuk hukum formil. Keempat, kerapuhan perlindungan berlapis dua, yaitu pada status norma dan pada pelaksanaannya, sekaligus merupakan manifestasi kelembagaan dari terpinggirkannya hifz al-mal. Implikasinya, perbaikan tidak dapat ditempuh melalui sosialisasi melainkan melalui pemindahan materi rumusan kamar agama menjadi Peraturan Mahkamah Agung, reformulasi Pasal 149 Kompilasi Hukum Islam, dan pengaktifan Pasal 95 ayat (1) sebagai instrumen preventif.
Reconstructing Administrative Due Process in Algorithm-Based Government Decision-Making
1249-1269
This study examines the adequacy of Indonesia's administrative law framework in safeguarding due process when government decisions are made or materially influenced by algorithmic systems. Using prescriptive doctrinal legal research, the study integrates statutory, conceptual, case, and functional comparative approaches and maps the legal framework through 54 indicators within a Six-Layer Administrative Due Process Model (DPA-6). The mapping identifies 19 indicators as available, 24 as ambiguous, and 11 as not yet specifically regulated. Existing law provides important foundations through legality, the General Principles of Good Governance, personal data protection, administrative remedies, electronic evidence, audit mechanisms, the Ombudsman, and administrative adjudication. The principal gaps concern meaningful human review, risk classification, algorithmic impact assessment, bias testing, system versioning, contestable explanations, and decision-level audit trails. The study proposes DPA-6 as an integrated lifecycle model covering legality and risk, pre-decision duties, notice and explanation, meaningful human review, effective administrative remedies, and audit, adjudication, and remediation. The model links citizens' rights, official responsibility, documentation, oversight, and remedies while preserving proportionality according to decision risk.
Article 411 of Indonesia’s Criminal Code and Bugis Customary Norms on Adultery: A Doctrinal Comparison
1498-1509
This study compares the offense of adultery under Article 411 of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code with discussions of adultery, siri’ and malaweng in Bugis customary-law scholarship. It uses normative legal research, combining statutory interpretation with a qualified review of written customary-law and ethnographic materials. The comparison addresses the prohibited act, protected interests, persons entitled to initiate proceedings, competent authorities, sanctions, objectives and sphere of application. Article 411 punishes sexual intercourse with a person other than one’s spouse, including intercourse between unmarried persons, and makes prosecution dependent on a complaint from statutorily designated family members. Cohabitation is a separate offense under Article 412. In the Bugis materials considered, breaches of sexual propriety may also implicate family honor and social relationships; however, malaweng is a broader category and customary procedures and sanctions vary by community and time. The article finds points of convergence in the protection of marriage and social order, but cautions against treating plural customary norms as a single enforceable regime. Customary reconciliation does not independently displace the procedural requirements of Article 411. The proposed framework requires location-specific empirical validation before claims can be made about contemporary customary enforcement.
Annulment of Marriage Due to Religious Differences and Unauthorised Polygamy (A Study of Supreme Court Decision No. 435 K/Ag/2026)
1761-1779
A subsequent marriage contracted while an earlier marriage remains legally subsisting, without judicial authorisation for polygamy, raises questions about capacity, validity and annulment, particularly when the parties also profess different religions. This article examines the doctrinal relationship between religious validity, the statutory impediment to remarriage and judicial annulment, with Supreme Court Decision No. 435 K/Ag/2026 as its reported case context. It adopts normative legal research using statutory, conceptual and case approaches. The analysis finds that religious differences under Article 2(1) of the Marriage Law and unauthorised polygamy under Articles 3–5 and 9 concern legally distinct questions. The absence of the required authorisation, alongside a subsisting earlier marriage, may support an annulment claim under Articles 22 and 24, independently of the broader debate over interfaith marriages. A decree must nevertheless safeguard children and the interests protected from retroactive effects under Article 28. The article proposes a three-stage reasoning framework addressing validity, the proven annulment ground and legal consequences. The full judicial reasoning still requires checking against the authenticated decision before case-specific conclusions are finalised.
Patriarchal Hegemony in the Enforcement of Domestic Violence Law in Indonesia: A Gramscian Analysis of the Gap between Law and Implementation
2071-2079
This normative legal study examines the gap between statutory protection of domestic-violence victims under Law Number 23 of 2004 and obstacles to implementation through Antonio Gramsci’s concept of hegemony. It distinguishes normalized patriarchal assumptions from coercion, economic dependence, and institutional weakness; analyzes the police duty of temporary protection and judicial protection orders; and compares the design of selected foreign protection mechanisms. CATAHU 2025 reporting statistics are used solely as contextual data on gender-based violence, not a measure of domestic-violence prevalence. The study finds that culturally legitimized subordination may contribute to barriers in accessing protection, but institution-specific claims require separate evidence. It prioritizes the twenty-four-hour police protection workflow, documented risk assessment, coordinated services, and a clear separation of administrative reform from legislative amendment.
Implementation of Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in the Settlement of Labor Disputes in Indonesia
600-617
This study aims to analyze the effectiveness of alternative methods in resolving labor disputes between employees and employers. The issue addressed is the continued dominance of litigation, which tends to be time-consuming, costly, and less likely to produce mutually beneficial solutions. Therefore, this research focuses on Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods, such as mediation, conciliation, and arbitration, as more effective and equitable mechanisms for dispute settlement. The research employs a normative juridical approach with qualitative analysis, utilizing secondary data in the form of laws and regulations, legal literature, and previous studies relevant to labor dispute resolution. The analysis is conducted descriptively and analytically to examine the effectiveness and implementation of ADR in Indonesia. The findings indicate that ADR methods, particularly mediation, play an important role in resolving labor disputes more quickly, flexibly, and in a manner that promotes mutually beneficial outcomes. However, their effectiveness still faces several challenges, including limited mediator competence, lack of understanding among the parties, and certain regulatory obstacles. In conclusion, ADR constitutes an important instrument for resolving labor disputes outside the court system; however, it requires stronger regulatory support, enhanced mediator capacity, and broader public awareness among the parties in order to ensure optimal legal certainty and justice.
Unlawful-Act Liability and the Supervisory Duties of the Financial Services Authority in Online Lending: A Critical Analysis of Cassation Decision Number 1206 K/Pdt/2024
This article critically analyses unlawful-act liability in the regulation and supervision of online lending by Indonesia's Financial Services Authority (OJK) through Cassation Decision Number 1206 K/Pdt/2024. It expressly separates the court's ratio and dispositive order from the authors' normative evaluation. The study uses normative legal research with statutory and case approaches, examining the LPBBTI rules applicable during the disputed period, subsequent regulatory developments up to 31 August 2026, and the elements of Civil Code Article 1365. The analysis focuses on the legal source of OJK's duty, unlawfulness, fault, loss, and causal connection, as well as the remedial character of a citizen lawsuit. It argues that supervisory failure cannot be inferred merely from consumer loss; causation must be tested through a specific legal duty, regulatory capacity to prevent the relevant risk, causal proximity, and the remedy sought. The decision is therefore treated as an object of critical legal analysis rather than authority for the proposition that OJK is civilly liable for every loss associated with online lending.
Criminal Liability for Demonstration Documentation under the ITE Law: Distinguishing Recording, Dissemination, and Criminal Assistance in Decision No. 1027/Pid.Sus/2025/PN Bdg
1120-1130
This article examines criminal liability for demonstration documentation by rigorously separating three distinct legal bases: recording an event, disseminating the resulting material, and intentionally assisting an underlying offence. Bandung District Court Decision No. 1027/Pid.Sus/2025/PN Bdg is used as a normative case study. The analysis combines statutory, case, and conceptual approaches to Law No. 1 of 2024 on Electronic Information and Transactions, Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024, and the former Criminal Code rules on criminal assistance applicable to the August 2025 tempus delicti. The study finds that the absence of professional-journalist status does not by itself make recording or dissemination “without right”. Criminal assistance requires intentional and functionally relevant facilitation of the principal offence; recording conduct after a completed violent act therefore does not automatically assist that completed act. Following Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024, Article 28(2) in conjunction with Article 45A(2) must be confined to intentional and public identity-based hate content that creates a real risk of discrimination, hostility, or violence. A closed WhatsApp transmission must consequently be distinguished from broader public social-media publication, while hostility toward the police as a state institution cannot simply be equated with hatred based on the protected identity grounds. The district-court decision is treated as an illustration of first-instance judicial reasoning rather than binding precedent.
Corporate Legal Liability for Environmental Pollution Caused by Processed-Food Industry Waste in Indonesia: PT Mayora Indah Tbk as a Documentary Illustration
1418-1428
This article analyzes the architecture of corporate legal liability for environmental pollution caused by processed-food industry waste in Indonesia and uses PT Mayora Indah Tbk only as a documentary illustration, not as an allegation of violation. The study applies normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and limited judicial-reference approaches. It distinguishes administrative, civil, and criminal liability; clarifies the polluter-pays principle and Article 87 civil liability; re-examines strict liability under Article 88 after the Job Creation amendments; and separates corporate attribution from the liability of directors or persons giving orders under Articles 116–119 of the Environmental Protection and Management Law and Supreme Court Regulation Number 13 of 2016. Corporate annual and sustainability disclosures are treated as self-reported evidence whose legal weight is limited unless verified against permits, technical approvals, monitoring data, inspections, PROPER results, or enforcement records. The article proposes a documentary-compliance matrix and an evidence-preservation model for wastewater cases. It concludes that Indonesia has multiple liability channels, but legal comprehensiveness should not be confused with enforcement effectiveness or proof of compliance by any particular company.
The Exercise of Local Government Authority in the Governance of Sustainable Tourism in Central Halmahera Regency
1666-1680
Through regional autonomy, local governments have the authority to carry out development in their respective regions, including the development and management of the tourism sector, which aims to improve the welfare of their communities. This study aims to examine the implementation of local government authority while also identifying good and sustainable governance practices for tourism development in Central Halmahera Regency. This study employs an empirical legal research design, utilizing data derived from on-the-ground tourism management practices, which are subsequently analyzed using relevant legal provisions through qualitative data analysis techniques. The results indicate that the local government of Central Halmahera Regency possesses strong attributive and delegated authority based on applicable laws and regulations. Consequently, it has a legal basis for formulating an overarching legal framework that legitimizes the implementation of tourism governance in Central Halmahera, grounded in the principles of social justice and the concept of a welfare-oriented rule of law that positions coastal and local communities as key actors. This study is expected to contribute theoretically to the development of the literature on regional fiscal law, while also providing practical recommendations for the local government in formulating more effective policies and strategies to optimize tourism revenue.
Harmonisation of the Mechanisms for Implementing Plea Bargaining in Money-Laundering Cases to Achieve Speedy, Simple and Affordable Justice in Indonesia
1916-1936
This normative comparative study assesses the legal limits of the guilty-plea mechanism in Article 78 of Indonesia’s Law No. 20 of 2025, especially its possible application to money-laundering prosecutions. The analysis contrasts Indonesia’s statutory conditions with US Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11 and Germany’s section 257c StPO, focusing on eligibility, judicial scrutiny, legal representation, factual verification, and third-party asset rights. The Indonesian mechanism should not be equated with unrestricted US plea bargaining: the statutory offence thresholds and procedural guarantees remain controlling. Any extension to otherwise ineligible laundering offences requires legislative amendment, not judicial inference alone. The proposed model separates a voluntary plea from independent proof of illicit proceeds, asset recovery, and protection of victims and bona fide third parties.
Copyright Protection of Video Game Characters in Indonesia: Unauthorized Modding, Derivative Works, And A Three-Tier Regulatory Framework
238-256
The expansion of the video game industry in Indonesia has intensified modding as a form of digital creativity while also exposing uncertainty over the legal boundaries of copyright protection for game characters. This article examines the legal status of video game characters, the qualification of unauthorized modding under Indonesian copyright law, and the regulatory reconstruction required to address the resulting grey areas. The study employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, comparative, and case approaches. Its principal legal materials include Law Number 28 of 2014 on Copyright, digital-law instruments, derivative-work doctrine, end-user licence agreements, technological protection measures, and scholarship on modding practices. The analysis finds that modding involving adaptation, transformation, public distribution, commercialization, or circumvention of technological protection measures may engage the exclusive rights of copyright holders, while private, non-commercial and non-distributive modifications remain less clearly regulated. The article develops a three-tier regulatory framework combining risk-based legal classification, institutionalized community licensing, and proportionate platform accountability. This framework is intended to protect legitimate copyright interests without eliminating socially valuable forms of participatory digital creativity.
Effectiveness of Government Accountability in Sustainable Development-Based Urban Waste Management (SDGs): Case Study of the Bantar Gebang Integrated Waste Management Site
257-272
Urban waste management at the Bantar Gebang Integrated Waste Management Site (TPST) faces various challenges in achieving sustainable development while fulfilling government responsibilities. This study analyzes the fulfillment of the environmental dimensions of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), together with the legal constraints and implications of the accountability of the Provincial Government of DKI Jakarta. The findings show that the fulfillment of the SDGs, particularly Goals 11, 12, and 13, remains suboptimal because open dumping continues to be prioritized in the waste-management process despite its prohibition under Law Number 18 of 2008. This condition has indirectly contributed to the accumulation of 55 million tons of waste, environmental pollution, and a waste landslide that killed several people in March 2026. The main obstacles to effective waste management include ambiguity in cross-jurisdictional authority between Jakarta and Bekasi, dependence on environmentally unfriendly technology, and weak administrative-law enforcement. The legal implications include non-compliance with administrative sanctions, the potential for class actions and citizen lawsuits under Law Number 32 of 2009, and the designation of the former Head of the DKI Jakarta Environmental Agency as a criminal suspect. The study concludes that government accountability remains ineffective and requires systemic and governance improvements, including source-based waste reduction, optimization of environmentally friendly technology, and stronger interregional coordination.
Rights-Based School Governance in Indonesia: Reconstructing Educational Management for Student Protection Under the 2026 Safe and Comfortable School Culture Framework
273-299
This article examines how educational management can be reconstructed as a governance mechanism for fulfilling and protecting students' rights within Indonesian education law, particularly following the 2026 regulatory shift toward a Safe and Comfortable School Culture. Using normative legal research, the study combines statutory and conceptual approaches. Primary legal materials include constitutional guarantees, education, child-protection, disability and personal-data legislation, as well as the latest school-management and safe-school regulations. Secondary materials comprise recent Indonesian and international peer-reviewed scholarship on education rights, inclusion, student voice, school leadership, safety and institutional accountability. The analysis finds that students' rights extend beyond formal access to schooling and encompass continuity of learning, substantive equality, physical and psychological safety, sociocultural and digital security, reasonable accommodation, meaningful participation, accessible complaints and effective remedy. The article develops a Rights-Based School Governance (RBSG) model with six interdependent dimensions: legal alignment and rights mapping; inclusive planning and equitable resource allocation; a safe and dignified learning environment; meaningful student participation; accessible complaint, response and remedy; and rights-based monitoring, evaluation and accountability. The model translates abstract legal duties into auditable managerial processes while preserving professional authority and institutional proportionality.
Educator Management Policy from the Perspective of Education Law: Between Professionalism and Rights Protection
300-315
This article examines how educational management can operate as a governance mechanism for fulfilling and protecting students' rights within Indonesian education law following the 2026 Safe and Comfortable School Culture reform. The study uses normative legal research combining statutory and conceptual approaches with a structured purposive review of relevant scholarship. The analysis maps legal bases, duty-bearers, managerial functions, implementation mechanisms, and auditable evidence. The findings organize students' rights into access and continuity, equality, safety, reasonable accommodation, participation, and accessible complaint and remedy. From this synthesis, the article proposes a Rights-Based School Governance (RBSG) model with six parallel dimensions: legal alignment and rights mapping; inclusive planning and equitable resource allocation; a safe and dignified learning environment; meaningful student participation; accessible complaint, response and remedy; and rights-based monitoring, evaluation and accountability. The model translates legal duties into process ownership, documentary evidence, proportional safeguards, and review triggers while also recognizing procedural protection for educators. RBSG is a normative construction rather than an empirically validated intervention. Its feasibility, administrative burden, indicator validity, and effects on safety, inclusion, trust in complaint mechanisms, and continuity of learning therefore remain propositions for future multi-site empirical testing.
Integrating Environmental Approval into Mining Business Licensing: Corporate Accountability and Ecological Risk
316-337
This article examines the integration of environmental approval into mining business licensing following the consolidation of Indonesia's risk-based licensing regime. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and critical policy approaches, supported by an inventory and systematic interpretation of primary legal materials and recent scholarship. The study finds that integration can improve procedural certainty, but it also produces four accountability-risk indicators: blurred separation between environmental assessment and license issuance, incomplete public decision trails, asymmetric central-regional supervisory authority, and a weak operational link between environmental violations and the status of business licenses. These risks are particularly significant in mining because ecological impacts are spatial, cumulative, and long term. The article proposes a five-stage ecological accountability framework covering pre-licensing, license issuance, supervision, sanctions, and restoration. The framework requires meaningful public participation, accessible environmental data, field verification, responsibility of permit holders and beneficial controllers, and enforceable reclamation and post-mining guarantees. The central argument is that procedural simplification is legally acceptable only when it does not become substantive deregulation of environmental control.
Continuous Voter Data Updating and Election-Stage Verification: Protecting Constitutional Voting Rights in Indonesia
338-350
Continuous Voter Data Updating shifts Indonesian voter-list governance from a predominantly episodic model toward data maintenance throughout the electoral cycle. This study examines the normative position of PDPB, its functional relationship with voter-list updating during formal election stages, and its implications for protecting voting rights. The study uses normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and analytical approaches. Its principal legal materials include election legislation, KPU regulations on PDPB and voter-list preparation, population-administration law, personal-data-protection law, and Constitutional Court decisions concerning voting rights. The findings show that PDPB and election-stage updating are complementary rather than substitutive. PDPB maintains the voter database between elections, while election-stage procedures provide factual verification, correction, public scrutiny, and final legal establishment. The appropriate design is an integrated cycle linking population-data synchronization, field verification, Bawaslu oversight, public participation, and privacy safeguards. The article therefore reframes PDPB as a preventive constitutional-rights mechanism embedded in electoral governance. It also proposes an operational matrix for evaluating legal basis, institutional responsibility, verification, privacy protection, participation, and measurable performance indicators
Bond-Based Legal Immunity and the Rule of Law: A Comparative Study of Indonesia’s Patriot and Merah Putih Bonds With Argentina’s Treasury Bond Amnesty Scheme
351-379
This study examines the legal protection attached to special sovereign debt instruments in Indonesia through Patriot Bonds and Merah Putih Bonds under Article 50A of Law No. 4 of 2026 amending Law No. 4 of 2023 on Financial Sector Development and Strengthening, and compares it with Argentina’s asset-disclosure and tax-regularization regime under Law No. 27,260 of 2016, including the bond-related facilities provided within that framework. The study employs statutory financial immunity as an analytical category rather than as an established statutory classification to evaluate whether exceptional investor protection extends beyond legitimate investment certainty and materially limits ordinary criminal, civil, tax, evidentiary, or investigative mechanisms. The central issue concerns the tension between investor protection and state-financing objectives, on the one hand, and the rule of law, accountability, tax transparency, and anti-money laundering enforcement, on the other. Using a normative juridical method with statutory, conceptual, historical, and comparative-law approaches, the study analyzes primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials through systematic, historical, conceptual, and comparative interpretation. The findings show that the Indonesian framework attaches significant statutory protection directly to qualifying purchases of Patriot Bonds and Merah Putih Bonds, whereas Argentina links bond-related benefits to prior asset disclosure, fiscal regularization, eligibility requirements, and continuing compliance obligations. The comparison further demonstrates that legal protection affecting prosecution, taxation, evidentiary use of financial data, and access to information requires clear limitations, source-of-funds safeguards, and effective institutional oversight. The study concludes that the Indonesian framework may be characterized as a potential bond-based model of statutory financial immunity only where the operative legal provisions cumulatively satisfy the conceptual criteria developed in this study. Any such protection can be normatively justified only if it remains limited, conditional, proportionate, risk-based, and compatible with effective enforcement against money laundering, tax crimes, and other serious economic offences.
Convergence and Divergence in the Regulation of Capital Punishment in Indonesia and Thailand: Implications for Criminal Law Reform in Southeast Asia
380-400
Capital punishment remains one of the most debated sanctions in criminal law, raising questions about enforcement effectiveness and human rights protection. Indonesia and Thailand, both retentionist states in Southeast Asia, retain the death penalty despite differing regulatory characteristics and reform trajectories. This study analyzes convergence and divergence in capital punishment regulation between the two jurisdictions and examines implications for criminal law reform in Southeast Asia. Using a normative comparative legal method combining statutory, conceptual, and functional approaches, the study draws on primary legal materials, including legislation and international instruments such as the ICCPR and its Second Optional Protocol, alongside Scopus-indexed literature. Findings show both countries converge in retaining capital punishment for serious offenses, particularly premeditated murder and drug crimes, yet diverge in reform models. Indonesia's 2023 Criminal Code introduces a conditional death penalty with a ten-year probationary mechanism permitting commutation, while Thailand pursues a restrictive model narrowing death-eligible offenses and regulating execution procedures. Neither state has ratified the Second Optional Protocol; reform reflects domestic accommodation of ICCPR Article 6 rather than treaty-mandated abolition. Applying Nelken's theory of legal divergence, the study concludes that shared international pressures produce distinct, domestically mediated reform pathways rather than uniform regional convergence toward one model.
The Limits of a Prosecutor's Authority to File Appeals and Cassation Petitions Against a Defendant Whose Detention Period Has Expired Under the New Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP)
401-424
Reform of criminal procedural law through Law Number 20 of 2025 concerning the Criminal Procedure Code (New Criminal Procedure Code) brings changes to the regulation of legal action and detention. This article analyzes the limits of the public prosecutor's authority in filing appeals and cassation when the defendant's detention period has ended, from the perspective of human rights, legal certainty, proportionality and correctional overcapacity. This research uses normative juridical methods with statutory, conceptual, case and comparative approaches. The research results show that the end of the detention period does not automatically eliminate the public prosecutor's right to file legal action. However, the end of the detention period ends the previous basis for detention, so that detention at the appeal or cassation stage must be based on new authority and determinations in accordance with the New Criminal Procedure Code. Detention without a valid legal basis has the potential to violate the right to freedom and legal certainty. Specifically for acquittal decisions, defendants who are still detained must be released from the moment the decision is pronounced and an acquittal decision cannot be challenged by cassation. Therefore, it is necessary to harmonize norms and strengthen judicial supervision so that legal measures are not misused as a means of maintaining detention and to guarantee the protection of human rights.
Strengthening Blue Economy Law through the Role of Red and White Cooperatives in Sustainable Development
425-450
The blue economy is a development paradigm that emphasizes the sustainable use of marine resources by paying attention to ecological, social and economic aspects. Indonesia as a maritime country has great potential to develop a blue economy, but its implementation still faces various obstacles, both from a regulatory and institutional perspective. This article aims to analyze the strengthening of the blue economy law through the role of the Red and White Village/Subdistrict Cooperative as a forum for the people's economy. The research method used is a juridical-normative approach by examining related laws and regulations, legal doctrine, and cooperative institutional construction. The results of the analysis show that the Red and White Village/Subdistrict Cooperative normatively has the potential as an institutional instrument in supporting the blue economy through the function of organizing community businesses, strengthening the marine economic value chain, distributing economic benefits, and empowering coastal communities. However, the legal framework that regulates the relationship between cooperative law, maritime law and the principles of environmental sustainability still shows a fragmentation of norms so that harmonization of regulations and strengthening of sectoral policies is needed. The conclusions of this research are limited to a normative analysis of the legal design and institutional potential of cooperatives, not to measuring the actual effectiveness of cooperatives as blue economy actors because they have not been supported by empirical testing of institutional performance, governance capacity, or economic and ecological impacts at the community level. Further research needs to be directed at empirical studies regarding the effectiveness of the Red and White Village/Kelurahan Cooperatives in blue economy practices, including aspects of governance, access to financing, supply chains, environmental compliance, and their contribution to improving the welfare of coastal communities.
Legal Pluralism in the Era of Deregulation: Reconstructing the Regulatory Framework of Customary Forest Recognition
451-472
This article examines the tension between legal pluralism and deregulation in Indonesia’s customary forest recognition framework, focusing on the persistence of layered administrative requirements for rights that are constitutionally acknowledged. The study employs a juridical approach combining statutory, conceptual, and case analyses. It examines the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Law Number 41 of 1999 on Forestry, the post-Job Creation regulatory framework, and Constitutional Court Decision Number 35/PUU-X/2012. The analysis finds a regulatory asymmetry: deregulation has simplified and accelerated business access to forest-related resources, while customary forest recognition remains dependent on prior recognition of indigenous legal communities and, in particular regulatory configurations, regional legal instruments. This dependency transforms recognition that should be declaratory into a procedure resembling constitutive state authorization. The article proposes a declaratory recognition model based on registration and legal verification, time-bound administrative decisions, interim protection for claimed territories under review, integrated participatory mapping, and an objection mechanism for third parties. Under this model, the state confirms a pre-existing legal status rather than creating the underlying customary right. Such reconstruction would align legal certainty with constitutional recognition, reduce procedural inequality, preserve safeguards against overlapping claims, and make deregulation compatible with legal pluralism and ecological justice.
A Critical Constitutional Analysis of Expanding the State Budget Deficit Limit through a Government Regulation in Lieu of Law (Perppu): Assessing the “Compelling Urgency” Requirement
473-505
This study examines the discourse surrounding the proposed increase in Indonesia’s state budget (APBN) deficit beyond the statutory ceiling of 3% of GDP through a Government Regulation in Lieu of Law (Perppu). The research is motivated by intensifying global economic pressures arising from geopolitical tensions in the Middle East, particularly disruptions to global energy supply chains that may significantly affect Indonesia as a net oil-importing country. Nevertheless, this study argues that external shocks alone do not account for fiscal deficit pressures, as internal fiscal inefficiencies and policy choices may also contribute to the deterioration of the fiscal position. From a constitutional and legal perspective, the proposed policy must be assessed against Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance and Article 22 of the 1945 Constitution, as interpreted by Constitutional Court Decision No. 138/PUU-VII/2009, which establishes the constitutional parameters for the issuance of a Perppu based on the existence of a “compelling urgency.” This research employs a normative juridical method complemented by statistical analysis of global oil price movements, fiscal deficit developments, and capital outflow indicators. The analysis focuses on whether the proposed expansion of the deficit ceiling is attributable exclusively to external economic shocks and whether the issuance of a Perppu satisfies the constitutional requirements of a “compelling urgency.” The study argues that the proposed policy may not fully satisfy this constitutional criterion because a portion of the fiscal pressure derives from internally generated inefficiencies, creating what may be characterized as a form of “self-inflicted urgency.” Accordingly, mechanisms provided under the existing budgetary framework, particularly an amendment to the APBN (APBN-P), may constitute a more constitutionally appropriate and procedurally accountable alternative to the issuance of a Perppu.
Academic Welfare of Non-ASN Lecturers: A New State Responsibility in Higher Education
506-531
Non-ASN lecturers play a substantive role in higher education by carrying out teaching, research, community service, academic supervision, and scientific development. However, their academic obligations are not always followed by adequate legal protection of income and welfare. This article examines the position of academic welfare for non-ASN lecturers within the framework of the welfare state and formulates a new direction of state responsibility in ensuring decent income in higher education. This study uses normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and policy approaches. The findings show that academic welfare is not merely an internal employment issue between lecturers and higher education institutions, but a legal issue connected to the public function of higher education, university autonomy, and the constitutional mandate of the state. Academic welfare should be understood as a minimum protection framework that enables lecturers to perform the tridharma of higher education with dignity, productivity, and sustainability. The state’s responsibility must therefore be directed toward establishing minimum income standards, ensuring social protection, clarifying legal status, integrating lecturer welfare into higher education funding policy, and placing academic welfare as part of higher education quality assurance.
The Dual Role of Career Women in Strengthening Family Resilience: Perspectives of Islamic Law and Indonesian Positive Law among Employees of STAI As-Sunnah Deli Serdang
532-546
This study analyzes how career women manage dual roles to maintain family resilience and examines those experiences through Islamic law (Maqashid Sharia) and Indonesian positive law. The case study focuses on married female employees at STAI As-Sunnah Deli Serdang. Data were obtained through in-depth interviews, observation, and institutional documents and were analyzed using the Miles and Huberman interactive model, with triangulation across available sources. The findings indicate that family resilience is supported by participatory spousal cooperation (ta'awun), support from extended family or domestic assistance, and flexible priority management. From a Maqashid Sharia perspective, paid work may support hifz al-din, hifz al-'aql, and hifz al-mal, while pressures arising from workload and caregiving require attention to hifz al-nafs and hifz al-nasl. The legal review also shows that the reported internal practice of 30 days of maternity leave should not be assessed solely under Article 82 of Law No. 13 of 2003. The current framework includes Law No. 4 of 2024 on Maternal and Child Welfare, which provides a maternity-leave entitlement of at least three months and allows an additional period in specified conditions. Because the manuscript does not include the institution's final formal policy document or complete employment-status data, a definitive finding of institutional non-compliance requires documentary verification.